Skip to content
https://kiskadeewatch.com/opinion/editorial/chinese-landing-confrontation/
Editorial

Chinese Landing confrontation 

This is outrageous.  After this latest conflict between miners and the Carib Chinese Landing community which ended in injuries on both sides, Natural Resources Minister Vickram Bharrat described the latest development as “criminal in nature, not mining related.” Where is he living? Does he really not follow events which happen in his own sector?  He needs to get himself up to speed about what his portfolio involves, because at bottom this is all about miners transgressing the law and international mandates to take gold from Amerindian titled lands.

While this confrontation has been going on for years, there was President Irfaan Ali two weeks or so ago addressing the Global Diversity Alliance in Georgetown where he reiterated plans to conserve a large forest landscape here and protect 30 per cent of this country’s lands and waters by 2030. This did not include Chinese Landing, it seems. Where this unfortunate community is concerned the government has come out unambivalently on the side of illegal miners, never mind the environmental and health damage they are causing. So much for the conservation of forests.

The miners have been working concessions in Tassawini, which falls well within Chinese Landing’s title, and in recent months they have been trying to bring in heavy-duty machinery to the area. Having had little success with government agencies, the community’s Toshao, Nikita Miller, and other members of the village have changed tactics and have been trying to block mining equipment being taken to Tassawini.

This began in August, when residents observed that at least nine excavators, two bulldozers and several dredge engines being transported on barges. They were thought to be registered to miner Mr Wayne Vieira.

Among other things the community blocked the road, and more recently the miners used aircraft to transport fuel in. Their latest effort involved trying to access Tassawini through a neighbouring village called Kariako, and it was here the violence took place when the Chinese Landing Toshao and others tried to stop them. The GGMC had earlier become involved in a mediation effort between the two sides, but withdrew on September 7th because, according to the Commissioner, the initiative appeared “to have been overtaken by developments and circumstances affecting both sides.”

In the course of the recent clash with the miners Ms Miller described how one resident was bloodied, while she was given a “thrashing” and was held down in the mud. Her phone was taken as was her licensed firearm. A bike provided by the Ministry of Natural Resources was stolen along with another belonging to a resident.  The miner, she related, fired ten shots over their heads during the attack.

She explained that the residents had taken control of the excavator the miners were trying to bring through Kariako which is when the miner and his employees launched a counter-attack. The version issued by the Guyana Gold and Diamond Miners Association was very different, with it asserting that legitimate miners had been attacked by illegal miners and demanding immediate police action. The legitimate miners, the Association said, were receiving “urgent medical care.”

There seems to be no doubt that it was not just the Chinese Landing villagers who received injuries; at least one miner if not more clearly did too. Moreover it was the former’s seizure of the excavator which triggered the fracas in the first instance. However, there are problems in other respects with the Association’s press release including a certain lack of acknowledgement of the laws under which its members are operating.

Its assertions about “illegal miners” who are pretending to be “victims” is a presumed reference to members of the Chinese Landing community whom they are accusing of being engaged in small-scale mining. Whether or not there is any substance in that allegation, it should be noted it is a traditional Amerindian mining privilege reserved in the legislation.

That right notwithstanding, the government still issued a Stop Mining Order in 2023 to prevent the villagers from mining, despite the fact it had no legal sanction in the Mining Act for this. At the same time, it allowed Mr Vieira and his associates to continue in clear breach of the law. Why the government will not lift what is an illegitimate Stop Mining Order speaks volumes about its attitude to Indigenous rights.

The Association goes on to claim that the Chinese Landing issue had been settled by Guyana’s highest court, the CCJ, in favour of Mr Vieira. It hasn’t.

What happened was that some years ago the GGMC had issued a Cease Work Order to Mr Vieira, and he had taken the matter to court to have it reversed. Unfortunately, the Commission had used the Mining Regulations and applied them to the Amerindian Act when they could only be used under the Mining Act. This bit of legal incompetence meant that the Cease Work Order was thrown out.

In other words Mr Vieira won his case on a legal technicality, but the decision in no way confirmed his mining rights on Amerindian titled land. Furthermore, no government agency following the CCJ decision made any move to bring a properly argued case related to the substantive matter at issue to court. And so both Mr Vieira, his mining associates and even the government still cling to the fiction that Mr Vieira is mining legally in Tassawini as determined by the CCJ, and the Chinese Landing residents are the ones in the wrong.

The first thing to be said is that Chinese Landing’s title to the lands of Tassawini are not in dispute. Ms Janette Bulkan has pointed out that the permits which were issued to Mr Vieira should not have been, because they name ‘State Land’, when Chinese Landing is private land, and the permits exclude all land lawfully held and titled. She alludes to various other defects in the decision to grant the permits to Mr Vieira as well as the fact that he is in default in various respects of the applicable legislation.

Of course what Mr Vieira and by implication the state agencies involved in this story hang on to tenaciously is the fact that there was an agreement with the Chinese Landing Village Captain in 1998 and 1999, who has been described as almost “non-literate” and who didn’t really understand what was involved. However, other members of the village did and they sent a substantial number of petitions to various government agencies to no effect.

According to the APA the mining operations became a source of conflict after the agreement was not renewed in 2004. There were more attempts at renewal in 2009 which came to nothing, although mining continued in Tassawini without the approval of the Village Council. Under the law Indigenous communities have the right to accept or refuse medium-scale mining on their lands, and Mr Vieira simply does not have their acceptance.

The GGMC appears to have been unconcerned about the law, and still renewed the permits in 2010, even though by that time the Amerindian Act was in effect and they should have first notified the village and then satisfied themselves that mining would not have a harmful impact on it, neither of which they did.

The APA has cited the damage mining has done to the area in terms of polluting water courses, destroying farms and interfering with traditional livelihoods. This is in addition to increased mercury levels and a variety of health issues affecting residents.

The Chinese Landing community went international with their concerns, something which annoyed the PPP/C government immeasurably. UNCERD recommended that the administration revoke the mining concessions affecting Chinese Landing among others, while the IACHR issued a resolution in 2023 granting precautionary measures saying members of the community were “currently at serious, urgent risk of suffering irreparable harm to their human rights”.

The government here took no notice.  And now we have the ill-informed Minister Bharrat using words like “criminal” for what happened, when the events were a consequence of not just the total inaction of himself and other ministers, but also their unquestioning support of bullying miners operating illegally on Indigenous land. In such circumstances the community has few options.

One supposes the police will be sent in to act heavy-handedly as the GGDMA has asked, although the ruling party did nothing or very little in the past about innumerable acts of violence perpetrated by miners against the Chinese Landing residents that were reported. The previous Toshao was allegedly warned that if the village won back its lands the miners would not leave easily and people would die.

Well there is no danger of that it seems. Mr Bharrat saved his words of comfort for the miners alone:  the government is not considering suspending mining activities in the Chinese Landing area.

You reached the end of this article without encountering a paywall.

That is deliberate. We believe reliable journalism about Guyana should be available to everyone from the hinterland to the coast, including those who cannot afford to pay for it. But investigating, reporting and publishing every story takes time, energy and resources. Keeping our journalism open depends on the commitment of readers who can chip in and contribute to help cover the cost for everyone.

Please join the Kiskadee family by taking a subscription. Every contribution counts to our commitment to our journalists, to our readers, and to independent, public-interest journalism.

And please spread the word. One one dutty build dam!

Become a supporter