The Director of Public Prosecutions (DPP) Shalimar Ali-Hack has filed an application under the Judicial Review Act (JRA) seeking to quash the decision of Chief Magistrate Judy Latchman not to revoke the bail of Azruddin Mohamed granted in extradition proceedings after he was linked to a number of subsequent criminal complaints.
This matter is to come up for urgent hearing before Chief Justice (ag) Navindra Singh on November 23rd. It was the latest twist in a battle between the state and Mohamed over other matters that have surfaced since the extradition proceedings including the October 12 incident in Kitty where Mohamed was arrested after a shooting outside the home of Police Special Branch Head Prem Narine.
The documents in this matter were served on Mohamed in the Lusignan Prison on Friday afternoon. The filing by the DPP could also have an impact on bail proceedings for Mohamed scheduled for Tuesday before Justice Priscilla Chandra-Hanif.
While the application under the JRA has been filed by the DPP the application would essentially be seen as an action on behalf of the United States which is the requesting state in the extradition proceedings before Magistrate Latchman.
The DPP is seeking an order of certiorari, quashing the decisions of the Chief Magistrate made on the 2nd and 3rd days of November 2026 in the matter of United States of America v Nazar Mohamed, Azruddin Mohamed Case Jackets No. 4716 &
4717 of 2025 whereby she refused an application to revoke Mohamed’s bail.
The DPP is praying for a Declaration that the decisions of the Chief Magistrate made on the 2nd and 3rd days of November 2026 in the extradition proceedings, refusing the Director of Public Prosecution’s application for the revocation of bail was made in a way that was:
i. unauthorized or contrary to law;
ii. failing to satisfy or observe conditions or
procedures required by law;
iii. unreasonable, irregular or improper exercises of
jurisdiction;
iv. in conflict with the policy of a Act(s); and
v. in error of law.
The DPP is also seeking a Declaration that, on the true and proper construction of section 7(1)(c) of the Bail Act, the establishment of the conditions prescribed therein does not require proof of a criminal conviction or proof beyond a reasonable doubt.
The DPP is also seeking an Order that the bail granted to the Interested Party by the Respondent in the Extradition proceedings be revoked.
In reciting the grounds for the application, the DPP said that on the 31st day of October 2025, the Chief Magistrate granted bail to Mohamed in the sum of $150,000 following an executed warrant for his arrest.
On the 2nd and 3rd November 2026, the DPP informed the Chief Magistrate that since the last hearing of the Extradition Proceedings, Mohamed had been arrested and charged with the offences of: unlawful possession of firearm without licence, contrary to s. 16(2)(a) of the Firearm Act; unlawful possession of ammunition without licence, contrary to s. 16(2)(a) of the Firearm Act; and attempting to obstruct the course of justice, contrary to s.330 of the Criminal Law Offences Act, in relation to an incident at almost midnight on 12 October 2026 where it was alleged that Mohamed and other men were apprehended after they were detected conducting surveillance of the home of Senior Superintendent Prem Narine a witness in the Extradition Proceedings.
The DPP said that the Chief Magistrate was further informed that Mohamed was also charged with breaching s. 9(2)(a) of the Cybercrime Act pertaining to an allegation that he was involved in the unauthorised downloading and sharing of video data of aspects of the incident from the police database.
The application said that the DPP submitted that Mohamed’s bail be revoked on the basis that he had committed offences whilst on bail, had interfered with witnesses, and that there was a substantial risk of similar misconduct.
The application said that the DPP advised the Chief Magistrate that police officers who could speak directly to the allegations were present and could be examined by the Chief Magistrate, but that Magistrate Latchman indicated that this was unnecessary.
The application said that the Chief Magistrate rejected the application reasoning that: had Mohamed been convicted while the Extradition Proceeding is still ongoing, that conviction may very well have some bearing on the application for revocation; charges by themselves, without more, do not satisfy the court that Mohamed has committed an offence or is likely to commit an offence; and that there must be something substantial that elevates the charge to satisfy the court that the defendant has committed an offence or is likely to commit an offence.
The DPP contended in the application that in refusing to revoke the bail of Mohamed, the Chief Magistrate made her decision in a way that was unauthorized or contrary to law; made a decision in error of law; made a decision in conflict with the policy of the Bail Act and other statutory provisions regarding bail; failed to satisfy or observe conditions or procedures required by law; and acted unreasonably, irregularly or improperly in exercising her discretion, took into account irrelevant considerations and/or failed to take into account
relevant considerations for the purpose of the extradition proceedings.
The DPP argued in the application that the High Court is vested with power to issue orders and directions in the interest of justice pursuant to Section 24 of the Supreme Court of Judicature Act, Cap 3: 02, Laws of Guyana and that the Chief Magistrate’s decision is reviewable by the High Court under the provisions of the JRA on grounds stated in the said Act.
The application was drawn on the DPP’s behalf by Celine Deidrick, one of the attorneys for the United States in the extradition case against Mohamed and his father Nazar Mohamed.
The application was accompanied by affidavits from another of the United States lawyers in the matter, Herbert McKenzie and Superintendent of Police Shellon Daniels who is prosecuting the case against Mohamed, Eugene Thorne and Mario Mohamed that arose after the October 12 shooting in Kitty. Daniels’ 88-page submission contained her affidavit and exhibits pertaining to the night of the shooting right up to the charge that police surveillance footage had been corruptly acquired by Azruddin Mohamed. It also contained a statement from Prem Narine on the events of October 12.
Discussion