-hearing, decision set for Tuesday
Opposition Leader Azruddin Mohamed remained behind bars on Friday after the High Court refused his application for interim bail but brought forward the hearing of his substantive challenge to a Magistrate’s decision to remand him to prison.
Justice Priscilla Chandra-Hanif ruled that while Mohamed’s continued detention raised serious questions concerning his constitutional right to personal liberty, the interests of justice were better served by urgently determining whether Magistrate Abigail Gibbs had acted lawfully when she refused him bail on October 30.
The Judge consequently moved the substantive judicial review hearing from November 23 to Tuesday, November 17, at 9 a.m., with a written judgment scheduled for 3 p.m. that same day.
The decision followed more than three hours of legal arguments on Thursday between Mohamed’s attorneys, led by Senior Counsel Roysdale Forde, and the State, represented by Attorney General Anil Nandlall SC and other counsel.
In delivering three judgments on Friday, Justice Chandra-Hanif made it clear that her refusal to grant interim bail had not determined whether Mohamed was ultimately entitled to bail, nor had it endorsed the legality of the Magistrate’s original decision.
Instead, the Court found that granting Mohamed temporary release before examining the substantive challenge could effectively provide the very relief being sought in the main proceedings, without first determining whether the Magistrate had committed any legal error.
The Judge recognised that every additional period of detention carried consequences for an individual who had not been convicted. However, she also considered the prosecution’s interests, the protection of witnesses, the integrity of criminal proceedings and the need for both sides to be afforded a fair opportunity to present their cases.
She determined that expediting the substantive hearing offered a more proportionate approach than granting interim bail on an incomplete examination of the evidence.
Importantly, the Court did not rule that the High Court was entirely without jurisdiction to grant interim bail during judicial review proceedings.
Justice Chandra-Hanif examined Section 10 of the Judicial Review Act, which provides for interlocutory orders and interim relief, and considered whether those powers could extend to bail in proceedings challenging a Magistrate’s decision.
Rather than making a definitive pronouncement on the extent of that jurisdiction in every such case, the Judge considered Mohamed’s application on the assumption most favourable to him, namely that the power to grant interim bail could exist.
Nevertheless, she found that the existence of such a power did not automatically entitle an applicant to its exercise, particularly where the substantive proceedings could be determined within a significantly shorter period.
Competing
The Court also considered the competing arguments advanced during Thursday’s hearing.
Nandlall had opposed the application on the basis that Mohamed’s attorneys had chosen judicial review as their legal remedy and could not use that procedure to circumvent the established legal framework governing bail.
He argued that the defence had other avenues available, including constitutional proceedings, through which particular forms of relief could be sought.
The Attorney General maintained that judicial review was concerned with examining the legality of the Magistrate’s decision, rather than conducting an entirely new bail hearing based on subsequent developments.
The State also argued that Magistrate Gibbs had considered the relevant factors before refusing bail and that the High Court should not prematurely interfere with her decision without first determining whether it was legally defective.
Mohamed’s attorneys, however, maintained that the High Court possessed the authority to grant interim relief to protect his constitutional rights while the substantive proceedings remained pending.
They argued that his continued imprisonment caused ongoing prejudice and that each additional day in custody represented a loss of liberty that could not be restored if the Court subsequently found that the Magistrate’s decision was unlawful.
The defence also raised concerns about delays in the proceedings and the State’s failure, at that stage, to file evidence responding to allegations contained in the application.
The urgency of the matter had been heightened by correspondence from the Attorney General following an earlier case management hearing, indicating that commitments connected to separate extradition proceedings could affect the timetable previously established by the Court.
Mohamed’s attorneys had objected to any further delay and sought either his immediate release or an accelerated determination of the substantive case.
Adjustments
Justice Chandra-Hanif ultimately accepted that the continued detention of an unconvicted person justified further adjustments to the Court’s timetable.
Under the revised directions, the respondents were required to file their affidavits in defence and detailed written submissions by Monday, November 16, at 10 a.m.
The applicant was then required to file any answering affidavit and written submissions by 6 p.m. that day.
The substantive hearing was scheduled to begin at 9 a.m. on Tuesday, with the Court expected to deliver its written judgment at 3 p.m.
The Judge also directed that the parties’ written submissions should contain their full legal arguments, with oral presentations confined to matters requiring clarification rather than a repetition of everything already filed.
Meanwhile, the High Court also ruled on separate applications challenging the affidavit evidence submitted by Mohamed and his mother, Bonita Mohamed, who instituted the judicial review proceedings on his behalf.
The Attorney General and Director of Public Prosecutions had objected to several portions of the affidavits, arguing that they contained hearsay, unsupported allegations, irrelevant material and legal submissions presented as factual evidence.
The objections formed a significant part of Thursday’s lengthy proceedings, during which Nandlall maintained that Mohamed’s attorneys could have obtained sworn evidence directly from him when the proceedings were first instituted.
He argued that Mohamed’s incarceration had not prevented his legal representatives from accessing him and that a subsequent affidavit sworn by the Opposition Leader could not retrospectively correct every deficiency in his mother’s original evidence.
In her rulings, Justice Chandra-Hanif agreed that affidavit evidence submitted in judicial review proceedings remained subject to the applicable Civil Procedure Rules and established principles governing admissibility. She found that the commencement of judicial review proceedings did not automatically make otherwise inadmissible evidence acceptable.
The Court therefore examined the material to distinguish matters within the personal knowledge of the persons making the affidavits from information obtained through third parties, unsupported assertions and legal arguments.
However, the Judge declined to strike out the entire application merely because some portions of the supporting evidence were inadmissible.
Offending
Instead, she ordered that the offending material be excluded or disregarded while allowing the substantive judicial review challenge to proceed.
The Court prepared detailed schedules identifying the paragraphs affected by its rulings and the evidence that would remain available for consideration during the substantive hearing.
Among the matters addressed were objections to portions of Mohamed’s supplementary affidavit, including paragraphs 16, 45, 53, 59, 61 and the first sentence of paragraph 76.
The Judge considered allegations concerning police conduct, social media commentary, political persecution and other matters that were not sufficiently connected to the legal question before the Court.
She emphasised that the exclusion of evidence did not amount to a finding that Mohamed’s substantive challenge lacked merit.
The central question remained whether Magistrate Gibbs had acted lawfully, rationally and fairly when she refused bail on October 30, based on the information and circumstances properly before her at that time.
The Court also addressed allegations concerning Mohamed’s conditions of detention at Lusignan Prison, including claims of prolonged isolation, continuous lighting, restrictions on exercise and difficulties consulting his attorneys.
Justice Chandra-Hanif acknowledged the seriousness of those allegations but explained that they concerned events and circumstances arising after the Magistrate’s decision.
Consequently, they could not automatically establish that the original refusal of bail had been unlawful.
The Judge made no findings on whether the allegations concerning Mohamed’s treatment in prison were true or false, explaining that such matters could be examined through appropriate legal proceedings.
She stressed that the judicial review application could not be transformed into a general inquiry into every development arising after the Magistrate’s ruling.
Before delivering her judgments, Justice Chandra-Hanif also issued a stern warning to attorneys, political commentators, the media and members of the public about the importance of accurately representing judicial decisions.
She acknowledged the principles of open justice, freedom of expression and the public’s legitimate interest in high-profile court proceedings.
However, she cautioned against selective interpretations, distorted reporting and attempts to use the Court’s decisions to advance political narratives.
The Judge made it clear that criticism and responsible reporting remained permissible, but warned that conduct amounting to contempt of court or improper interference with the administration of justice could attract legal consequences.
She emphasised that the Court’s decisions were based on the law and evidence before it, rather than political affiliation, public sentiment or external pressure.
Expedite
Following the rulings, Forde welcomed the decision to expedite the substantive hearing, describing it as a significant development in Mohamed’s efforts to secure his freedom.
Speaking to reporters outside the courtroom, he said the defence had sought both interim bail and an accelerated hearing and was satisfied that the Court had granted the latter.
Forde maintained that the proceedings had raised important legal questions concerning the availability of interim bail during judicial review proceedings.
He also welcomed the decision to bring forward the substantive hearing from November 23, particularly in light of the Attorney General’s earlier indication that separate court commitments could affect the original timetable.
The Senior Counsel expressed confidence that Mohamed’s legal team would secure a favourable ruling when the substantive challenge was determined on Tuesday.
Other members of the defence team similarly welcomed the expedited hearing, while criticising the time spent addressing procedural objections to affidavit evidence.
They maintained that the objections had not disposed of the central question concerning Mohamed’s entitlement to bail.
One defence attorney also complained that the State had not yet substantively answered serious allegations raised in the application, despite the time that had elapsed since the proceedings were initiated.
Nandlall, meanwhile, welcomed the Court’s decisions, particularly its rulings excluding portions of the affidavit evidence.
He maintained that the objections had been necessary to preserve the integrity of judicial proceedings and ensure that the Court considered only evidence permitted under the applicable rules.
The Attorney General argued that the administration of justice could not be compromised to accommodate the interests of any individual, regardless of political standing.
He pointed out that the Court had not dismissed the substantive judicial review application and said his objections had been directed at removing inadmissible material rather than preventing the challenge from proceeding.
Nandlall also maintained that allegations concerning Mohamed’s prison conditions belonged in separate proceedings and were not relevant to determining whether the Magistrate had acted lawfully when she originally refused bail.
He further addressed the Judge’s warning about public commentary, condemning attacks directed at female attorneys attached to the Attorney General’s Chambers who had appeared in the proceedings.
He said the attorneys were carrying out their professional responsibilities and should not be subjected to personal attacks because of their involvement in the case.
Mohamed has remained in custody since October 30, when he and Police Constable Ryan Greene were remanded in connection with cybercrime charges arising from the alleged unauthorised obtaining and disclosure of police surveillance footage linked to the October 12 shooting incident outside the Kitty residence of Senior Superintendent Prem Narine.
The Opposition Leader has also faced separate criminal proceedings arising from that incident, while he and his father, Nazar Mohamed, have continued to contest extradition proceedings initiated following a request by the United States.
Although Friday’s decision meant Mohamed would remain in custody for the time being, the Court’s revised timetable significantly shortened the period before the legality of the Magistrate’s refusal of bail would be determined.
Discussion