Magistrate Abigail Gibbs has told the High Court that she refused Opposition Leader Azruddin Mohamed bail after concluding that the timing of several matters brought against him disclosed a “pattern” and gave her substantial grounds to believe he was likely to commit another offence if released.
Magistrate Gibbs set out her reasons in a memorandum attached to an affidavit sworn on November 16. Mohamed’s mother, Bonita Mohamed, is asking the High Court to quash the magistrate’s October 30 decision to refuse bail in a case involving police surveillance footage of a shooting in Kitty.
Bonita Mohamed’s application alleges apparent bias arising from an alleged connection between Magistrate Gibbs and a police officer involved in investigating the October 12 shooting. The application also challenges the length of the remand and argues that Magistrate Gibbs gave insufficient weight to Mohamed’s previous compliance with bail conditions, his family responsibilities and his ties to Guyana.
Magistrate Gibbs said she had read the affidavits filed by Bonita and Azruddin Mohamed. Except where she expressly admitted a matter, she denied the “allegations, assertions and averments of fact and law” in the supporting affidavit. She did not specifically address the alleged connection with the officer in her affidavit or in the attached memorandum. Attorney General Anil Nandlall SC had previously questioned how Bonita Mohamed came to know of the alleged connection as part of his challenge to portions of her affidavit.
Reasons for refusing bail
Magistrate Gibbs said she considered that Mohamed was already on bail in extradition proceedings and on charges of unlawful possession of a firearm, unlawful possession of ammunition and attempting to obstruct the course of justice. Those three charges concern alleged conduct on October 12.
“The Court recognizes that the No. 2 Accused is presumed innocent of each of those charges, and the Court has not treated any of them as proof that he committed an offence,” Magistrate Gibbs wrote. “However, considered together and in light of their temporal proximity, the matters presented by both the prosecution and the defence disclose a pattern.”
Magistrate Gibbs relied on Section 7(1)(a)(ii) of the Bail Act 2022 in finding that there were substantial grounds to believe Mohamed was likely to commit a further offence, other than one punishable only by a fine, if released. She said she weighed the interests of society against his right to liberty and the prejudice he could suffer in custody. She took into account the presumption of innocence, the time he had already spent in custody, the gravity of the charge, the penalty it carries and his personal circumstances.
Mohamed’s lawyers cited his position as Opposition Leader and a member of the National Assembly as evidence of his ties to the community and in support of their argument that he was unlikely to flee. Gibbs said her concerns arose from the nature of the allegation and the risk of further offending.
“The Guyana Police Force Command Centre is not an ordinary place of storage,” she wrote. “The charge alleges that the protected systems at the Command Centre were breached by unauthorized means. An allegation of this nature strikes at the integrity of the State’s security and law enforcement systems, and at public confidence in them.”
Magistrate Gibbs concluded that the seriousness of the alleged offence and the risk of further offending outweighed the considerations in favour of bail. She said her account drew on her recollection, a recording of the October 30 hearing and notes she made at the time.
Prosecution alleges $800,000 payment for footage
The charge against Mohamed and Police Constable Ryan Greene concerns footage of the October 12 shooting on Barr Street, Kitty. The prosecution alleges that the footage was obtained without authorisation from a protected computer system at the police command centre in Liliendaal on October 13 and given to Mohamed without lawful excuse or justification.
Prosecutor Darshan Ramdhani KC told the magistrate that the centre monitors approximately 3,000 cameras across Guyana. He alleged that Greene and another officer attached to the centre downloaded the footage and that Mohamed’s driver took Greene to Mohamed’s home, where the footage was played. The prosecution alleged that a payment of $800,000 was agreed upon and made. Ramdhani opposed bail, arguing that Mohamed could interfere with the investigation and that the other charges brought while he was on bail indicated a risk of further offending.
Senior Counsel Roysdale Forde argued that the charge was defective, that its particulars did not explain what constituted a threat to national security and that the State lacked the evidence needed to establish the offence.
Attorney-at-law Siand Dhurjon argued that Mohamed had a lawful reason to receive footage that could assist his defence, assuming the prosecution could prove its account. He said the defence did not concede that Mohamed had interacted with Greene and told the court that Mohamed had received footage from several serving police officers whom he described as whistleblowers. Dhurjon also said he had been instructed that police had deleted other relevant footage. Magistrate Gibbs said her task at that stage was to decide bail and that she had yet to assess whether the evidence established the elements of the offence.
High Court challenge
The shooting took place outside the Kitty residence of Police Special Branch Head, Senior Superintendent Prem Narine. Mohamed and Greene were remanded on October 30, and the criminal matter was adjourned to November 24.
Justice Priscilla Chandra-Hanif refused Mohamed interim bail on November 13 and brought forward the hearing of his substantive challenge from November 23 to November 17. A written decision was scheduled for 3 pm yesterday but following more than five hours of arguments, the Judge set aside this morning to deliver her decision.
Mohamed’s lawyers argued that each additional day in custody represented a loss of liberty that could not be restored if the High Court later found that bail had been unlawfully refused. They proposed that he surrender his travel documents, report regularly to police and have no contact with prosecution witnesses. Nandlall opposed interim release, arguing that the court should first determine the challenge to Magistrate Gibbs’s decision.
Discussion