-2021 inspection report found vessel `unseaworthy and requiring urgent dry docking’
The MV Barima’s Certificate of Registration was regarded as valid indefinitely, despite an expiry date of May 27, 2025, being visibly scratched out on the document, the Commission of Inquiry (CoI) into the July 18 capsizing tragedy heard yesterday.
Registrar of Ships at the Maritime Administration Department (MARAD) Gale Culley-Greene told the inquiry that she was guided by the department’s Director General that Certificates of Registration no longer carried expiry dates.
During questioning by Commissioner Nyree Dawn Alphonso, Culley-Greene was asked to examine the registration certificate and identify the dates appearing on the document. She identified May 28, 1951, as the date of issue, October 26, 2020, as the date of renewal, and May 27, 2025, as the expiry date, although the latter had been scratched out.
Asked what the scratched-out expiry date signified, Culley-Greene explained that certificates previously carried a five-year validity period, but she had subsequently been informed that updated Certificates of Registration would no longer have expiration dates.
“That was information that was told to me, but prior, there are still some Certificates of Registration that may have expiration dates,” she shared. Alphonso then asked who had informed her that Certificates of Registration no longer required expiry dates. “My Director General,” Culley-Greene responded.
Asked whether she could recall when that guidance was given, she said she could not remember the exact date, explaining that she was relatively new to the portfolio and had been guided by her Director General as situations arose.
The commissioner subsequently sought clarification on whether it was her understanding that once a Certificate of Registration was issued, it remained valid indefinitely. “Yes, that’s what I was being guided by my Director General, that that is so,” Culley-Greene responded.
Alphonso then asked whether this meant the MV Barima’s registration certificate remained valid despite the expiry date appearing on the document. “Well, that’s on the record. So, I would want to assume,” she responded.
Culley-Greene explained that the Certificate of Registration primarily establishes ownership and contains particulars of the vessel, while its operational safety falls under the responsibility of MARAD’s Maritime Safety Division.
She told the inquiry that the registration certificate is generated using information contained in a Certificate of Survey, which provides details such as the vessel’s particulars and engine information.
When Alphonso asked whether a vessel’s registration would remain effective even if an inspection revealed serious defects, Culley-Greene initially said she would want to think so because the registration certificate had no expiry date.
However, she clarified that registration and seaworthiness were separate matters. “The Certificate of Registration speaks of ownership. The seaworthiness of the vessel, that’s where the inspection report comes in,” she explained, adding that while registration could remain in existence, the Certificate of Inspection carried weight in determining the vessel’s operational status.
The commissioner also asked whether Culley-Greene had encountered any circumstances during her five years as Registrar that could result in a Certificate of Registration being suspended, withdrawn or cancelled. “Not that I’m aware of. I’m not being aware of any situation that warrants that,” she responded.
During questioning by Commissioner, Rear Admiral (Ret’d) Hayden Pritchard, Culley-Greene disclosed that she had not previously handled the MV Barima’s registration file before the tragedy. She said she was asked by the Director General to submit the file on July 20 – two days after the tragedy that claimed 100 lives – and had only received it again on the morning of her testimony.
Pritchard also examined MARAD’s record-keeping arrangements, with Culley-Greene acknowledging that the department does not have a developed archival system and continues to maintain vessel records manually. She said limited office space presented challenges for storing documents and that she had not yet examined every vessel file under her department’s responsibility.
She further disclosed that although she had recommended digitising the records, the initiative remained under the attention of the Director General, and she could not provide details of a formal implementation plan.
Commissioner Jasionowski, meanwhile, examined the contents of the MV Barima’s registration file and questioned the Registrar about an inspection report dated March 3, 2021. At his request, Culley-Greene read the report’s findings, which stated that the vessel was “unseaworthy and requires urgent dry docking.” The survey had been conducted on January 11, 2021.
Jasionowski also established that the Barima’s registration file did not contain the Certificate of Survey, which Culley-Greene identified as the primary document used to obtain technical particulars, including the vessel’s dimensions and tonnage, for its registration certificate. She acknowledged that she could not identify the source of the tonnage figures without that supporting document.
The commissioner further questioned whether the Registrar routinely examined inspection reports placed in vessel files. Culley-Greene said reading the reports was not mandatory, although she sometimes reviewed them to understand the condition of vessels. She also told the inquiry that she could not recall seeing reports declaring other ferries unseaworthy or being briefed on re-inspections following such findings. Jasionowski subsequently requested the registration files for approximately 10 other state-owned ferries.
Discussion