A crew member aboard the ill-fated MV Barima discouraged a passenger from taking a life jacket before the vessel departed, telling her that she did not need one because it would take up space and assuring her that the journey would be smooth, the Commission of Inquiry (CoI) heard yesterday.
Survivor Carlita Matabheek testified that she had approached a crew member wearing a blue shirt bearing the Transport and Harbours Department (THD) insignia to request a life jacket because she could not swim. However, she said the crew member told her: “You don’t need a life jacket, it will take up space.”
When she insisted that she could not swim and would need one if anything went wrong, he reportedly reassured her that “it’s a smooth ride.”
Matabheek said the crew member did not provide her with a life jacket, moving her to ask her husband to get one for her. He subsequently attempted to remove one from where they were stored, but was unable to do so.
She explained that the life jackets were difficult to remove, describing how her husband climbed onto a bench and attempted to pull one out but could not get it free.
Matabheek shared that there were numerous passengers, including children, aboard the ferry and that she recalled seeing more than 10 hammocks on the passenger deck, while she and other family members had to sleep on the floor because of limited space.
Her husband, Adam Matabheek, testified that the vessel was carrying approximately 190 to 200 passengers, possibly more, with many seated or lying on the floor because benches were occupied by passengers and goods. He also recalled seeing boxes, bags and other cargo on the passenger deck, while the lower deck was filled with goods, motorcycles, a car and a pickup.
Adam said the vessel was scheduled to depart Georgetown at 1:00 pm on July 18, 2026, but did not leave until approximately 3:30 pm. He testified that passengers received no announcement explaining the delay or informing them about safety procedures before departure.
He further told the inquiry that, during the journey, one of the vessel’s engines repeatedly cut off and restarted, with this happening approximately two or three times. According to him, he and his brother noticed the vessel leaning towards its right-hand side at about 9:00 pm, after he had woken from a short sleep.
He said the vessel appeared to be heading towards the shoreline before suddenly turning back towards the deeper waters. He recalled that it then entered rough waters before making a loud impact and capsizing within seconds.
Adam testified that there was no alarm to alert passengers that the vessel was going down, and many people were still asleep when the incident occurred. He said he attempted to retrieve a life jacket but was unable to remove one from its storage compartment, forcing him to jump into the water.
His wife, who could not swim, was later found holding onto part of a life jacket alongside another woman.
Carlita also recounted the terrifying moments as the vessel went under water, explaining that she held onto a bench as passengers and belongings were thrown across the deck. She eventually surfaced holding onto part of a life jacket, which helped keep her afloat.
She said she later encountered another woman in the water who was struggling to stay afloat and helped encourage her to hold on until they were rescued.
The couple eventually reunited in the water, along with Adam’s brother and another woman.
Adam testified that they were rescued the following morning by a civilian vessel, which subsequently transferred them to a Coast Guard boat. They were later taken to Charity, where they received medical attention before being transported to Ogle.
During questioning by the commissioners, Adam provided further details about the amount of cargo carried aboard the MV Barima, confirming that goods were stored not only on the lower deck but also in the passenger areas. He said boxes and other items were stacked in front of the saloon entrance, while large luggage bags were placed near the washrooms, making movement difficult. He recalled seeing approximately four motorcycles on the lower deck, as well as a van and a car.
Discussion