Opposition Leader Azruddin Mohamed remained behind bars yesterday after more than five hours of legal arguments failed to produce a ruling on his challenge to Magistrate Abigail Gibbs’ refusal to grant him bail.
Justice Priscilla Chandra-Hanif reserved her decision until today at 11 a.m., following proceedings that began at 9 a.m. and continued into the late afternoon.
The hearing examined whether the Magistrate had acted lawfully, rationally and fairly when she refused Mohamed bail on October 30 in connection with a cybercrime charge.
During his submissions, Attorney General Anil Nandlall SC argued that the Magistrate had been entitled to consider the circumstances surrounding Mohamed’s successive criminal charges when assessing the likelihood of further offences.
He maintained that the existence of a charge alone would not necessarily justify refusing bail, but its nature and surrounding circumstances could provide substantial grounds for concern.
Nandlall pointed to the extradition proceedings involving Mohamed and his father, Nazar Mohamed, and subsequent charges arising from the October 12 incident outside Senior Superintendent Prem Narine’s Kitty residence.
He argued that allegations involving obstruction of justice could not be considered in isolation from the proceedings to which they were allegedly connected.
The Attorney General also maintained that judicial review was not a fresh bail hearing and that the High Court’s responsibility was to determine whether the Magistrate’s decision was legally sustainable.
Mohamed’s legal team, led by Senior Counsel Roysdale Forde, challenged the refusal of bail, maintaining that his continued detention infringed upon his right to personal liberty and that the Magistrate’s decision warranted judicial intervention.
Yesterday’s hearing followed the Court’s refusal last Friday to grant Mohamed interim bail. However, Justice Chandra-Hanif expedited the substantive proceedings, bringing the hearing forward from November 23.
The Judge had initially scheduled her ruling for 3 p.m. Tuesday but deferred the decision following the lengthy arguments.
Mohamed has remained at Lusignan Prison since October 30 after being charged alongside Police Constable Ryan Greene over the alleged unauthorised obtaining and disclosure of surveillance footage connected to the October 12 shooting incident outside Narine’s residence.
The footage allegedly originated from the Guyana Police Force’s Safe Country surveillance system.
Mohamed’s mother, Bonita Mohamed, subsequently instituted judicial review proceedings challenging the Magistrate’s refusal of bail.
Discussion