-debate to continue Monday
Government and opposition MPs clashed over removing limits on former presidents’ benefits during an almost five-hour debate that was adjourned early yesterday morning.
Finance Minister Dr Ashni Singh defended a common framework for former office-holders while opposition speakers questioned its fairness and cost.
Singh said the Former Presidents’ Benefits and Other Facilities Bill would repeal the 2015 Act and restore the arrangements enacted in 2009. He maintained that it would principally change the law applying to former President David Granger, since a court ruling had protected Samuel Hinds, Bharrat Jagdeo and Donald Ramotar from the later restrictions. He should have mentioned that President Irfaan Ali would also be a beneficiary when his presidency ends.
Speaker Manzoor Nadir adjourned proceedings at 1.08 am after 10 of the 17 scheduled speakers had completed their contributions. The debate will resume on Monday.
Moving the second reading, Singh argued that former presidents retained public obligations, security concerns and a special status after leaving office, irrespective of their political affiliations or how their records were judged.
“When we honour a former president, we honour ourselves,” he said.
He rejected the contention that the 2009 legislation had been intended to introduce unlimited benefits, saying it placed existing arrangements on a statutory footing and removed them from the discretion of the government of the day. Expenditure would remain subject to budgetary provision, he said.
APNU MP Sharma Solomon countered that respect for former presidents did not require the state to guarantee privileges without reasonable limits while ordinary citizens struggled.
“There is a difference between dignity and excess. There is a difference between reasonable entitlement and greed,” Solomon said. “Let me put it plain in the countryman language. This is pure greed.”
He said the dignity of the presidency must be protected, but the dignity of the people should not be sacrificed in doing so.
“We are not against dignity of the former presidents, none of them, and whoever becomes that, he or she,” he said. “We are against a Guyana where dignity is guaranteed at the top and has to be negotiated at the bottom.”
Solomon accused the government of securing comfort for those at the top while leaving working people to negotiate for improvements in their circumstances. He said Guyanese were entitled to share in the country’s wealth and to provide meals and education for their children without having to choose between basic necessities.
He also criticised the late-night consideration of the measure, suggesting that the government wanted the benefits settled before many citizens awoke.
Not challenging
WIN MP Vishnu Panday similarly said the opposition was not challenging the principle that former presidents should enjoy dignity and financial security. Its objection concerned the extent of the benefits and their relationship to ordinary pensioners’ incomes.
Panday distinguished between the “legal truth” of presenting legislation to Parliament and what he called the “common truth” of conscience and fairness.
He challenged Singh to reconcile the proposal with the government’s commitment to “putting people first”, arguing that the bill placed one office-holder ahead of the wider population.
Panday also challenged the impression that former presidents would be left without financial support unless the bill passed, noting that they already received pensions exceeding the incomes of many public servants.
He argued that removing expenditure limits ran counter to prudent financial management, which required the government to control costs rather than expand its obligations.
He also questioned why former presidents could not meet utility bills from their existing pensions and said prudent management required controlling expenditure.
Panday ended his contribution by describing the bill as “draconian and unconscionable”.
Singh’s defence rested substantially on the history of the legislation and the distinction between pension payments and other facilities.
Before 2009, he said, facilities other than the monetary pension were provided through Cabinet decisions or administrative discretion. The legislation introduced that year established a written framework against which their provision could be assessed.
Capriciously
“When benefits are provided by discretion they can be granted capriciously and they can be withdrawn capriciously,” he said.
Singh said the measure formed part of a wider effort to give statutory certainty to support for constitutional offices, including the spouse of the president and the Leader of the Opposition.
He argued that former presidents represented an extremely small category of persons who could not return to private life in the same way as other citizens. Their former office continued to carry obligations when travelling, participating in public affairs or addressing matters of national importance.
He also cited the PPP/C’s provision for Joyce Hoyte, the widow of former President Desmond Hoyte, as evidence that its position extended beyond party affiliation.
Tracing the restrictions introduced in 2015, Singh said the then opposition had first pursued caps while holding a one-seat parliamentary majority. An earlier bill did not become law because then President Donald Ramotar withheld assent.
The APNU+AFC government subsequently enacted the 2015 law, which imposed limits and restricted benefits where a former president engaged in paid employment, business or trade.
Singh described that legislation as an exercise in “political vindictiveness and retribution” directed at former PPP/C presidents.
He said a subsequent court ruling established that it could not retrospectively diminish the benefits of persons who had already become former presidents under the 2009 framework. Granger consequently became the first former president to whom the restrictions applied.
“Contrary to what might be asserted this bill does not change anything that applies to former President Samuel Hinds, former President Bharrat Jagdeo and former President Donald Ramotar,” Singh said. “Absolutely nothing.”
He maintained that the bill would restore a single framework rather than continue different treatment based on when a president left office.
Minister of Local Government Priya Manickchand supported the measure and argued that the state should provide security and reasonable comfort for former presidents regardless of political differences.
She also asserted that the government had not been applying the statutory caps to Granger’s utility and healthcare expenses.
“As we speak, we are breaking the law because we have not capped President Granger’s water bill. We have not capped his light bill. We have not capped his healthcare,” she told the House.
Manickchand said the expenses had been met out of gratitude and respect for the office Granger held. She challenged opposition MPs to say whether they wanted him to repay benefits received beyond the restrictions.
She rejected the argument that providing for former presidents meant neglecting ordinary citizens, pointing to investment in schools, teacher training, cash grants and school meals.
Manickchand also accused the former APNU+AFC administration of imposing additional taxes, withdrawing children’s cash grants and increasing ministerial salaries while now arguing that the proposed benefits were unfair to working people.
Had not made
Forward Guyana Movement MP Amanza Walton-Desir, however, said government speakers were answering an argument the opposition had not made.
“What the people of Guyana are saying is that these benefits cannot be uncapped,” she said.
She described as a “straw man argument” the suggestion that opposing the bill meant wanting former presidents to be denied dignity. She stressed that the proposed legislation concerned benefits, while former presidents already received pensions.
Walton-Desir questioned the urgency of removing the limits against the backdrop of high living costs, pressure on household incomes, shortages of health and education personnel, and child protection concerns.
She argued that references to the government’s achievements or the conduct of previous administrations did not answer the case against uncapped expenditure.
She also asked whether Granger had requested the changes being advanced in his name.
Another WIN speaker, Gobin Harbhajan, questioned the disparity between former presidents’ entitlements and the circumstances of retired public servants.
“The dignity of office is not sufficient reason to propose a huge and unreasonable benefit to those who serve as president,” he said.
He said some public servants worked for decades but still needed low-paid employment after retirement to meet living expenses. He also questioned unrestricted benefits where a former president pursued profitable business activities.
He recommended that the bill be referred to a special select committee for further consideration.
The bill remained before the House when the sitting was adjourned, with seven scheduled speakers still to contribute before the debate concludes.
Discussion