—raises concerns over treatment of Opposition Leader, Indigenous land rights
The Amerindian Peoples Association (APA) has warned of what it sees as growing erosion of the rule of law in Guyana, citing the treatment of Opposition Leader Azruddin Mohamed and continuing disputes over Indigenous lands.
In a statement, the association called for fair legal proceedings free from political interference, independent investigations into allegations of sexual violence, protection for citizens who speak out and respect for Indigenous Peoples’ individual and collective rights.
The APA said the contrasting approaches to allegations involving senior law enforcement officials and proceedings against political figures raised questions about selective enforcement, transparency and equality before the law.
“The Police Force must never become an instrument of political control or intimidation, nor should the administration of justice be influenced by political affiliation, social standing, or proximity to power,” it stated.
While recognising the responsibility of law enforcement agencies to investigate alleged wrongdoing, the association said everyone was entitled to the presumption of innocence, due process and equal protection under the law.
It expressed particular concern about the legal proceedings involving Mohamed and what it described as constant police harassment. Questions about the fairness, consistency and transparency of those proceedings needed to be addressed openly to maintain public confidence in the justice system, it said.
Mohamed has been on remand since October 30 in connection with a cybercrime charge concerning the alleged unauthorised disclosure of surveillance footage relating to the October 12 shooting outside Special Branch Head, Senior Superintendent Prem Narine’s Kitty residence. Mohamed and Police Constable Ryan Greene pleaded not guilty.
Justice Priscilla Chandra-Hanif on November 18 dismissed the application challenging Magistrate Abigail Gibbs’ refusal of bail. The judge found that the grounds for judicial review had not been established and said that, although pending charges were not proof of guilt, their surrounding circumstances could be considered when assessing the risk of further offending. Mohamed remains in custody at the Lusignan Prison.
The APA contrasted the treatment of Mohamed with the handling of serious allegations against Fazil Karimbaksh, who heads the Special Organised Crime Unit. It questioned whether the procedures under the Sexual Offences Act had been followed and called for a prompt, thorough, independent and impartial investigation.
The statement comes amid continuing questions about the progress of the investigation and Karimbaksh’s duty status. On November 16 Commissioner of Police Clifton Hicken had said the completed file would be sent to the Director of Public Prosecutions either the previous day or that day. Crime Chief Wendell Blanhum said it would be the second submission. Hicken did not confirm whether Karimbaksh remained on duty.
The APA also warned of an increasingly hostile environment for journalists, civil society representatives, environmental and human rights defenders, and other citizens who questioned government decisions.
Online harassment
It said reports of online harassment, coordinated personal attacks, threats and intimidation by persons perceived to be aligned with the government had contributed to a climate in which people feared expressing concerns. Public servants, it contended, were particularly reluctant to speak because of fears for their employment.
Freedom of expression was a constitutional right rather than a privilege granted by political authorities, the association said, urging political leaders and public officials to actively discourage intimidation, including online.
On indigenous rights, the APA pointed to insecure land tenure, encroachment on traditional territories, inadequate recognition of customary governance and decisions affecting lands and resources without free, prior and informed consent.
It cited Chinese Landing in the Moruca sub-region and Jawalla in the Upper Mazaruni as communities where unresolved concerns over mining, environmental pollution and incursions onto community lands continued to affect residents.
The arrest of Chinese Landing Toshao Nikita Miller and residents, it said, set a dangerous precedent for Indigenous Peoples defending their lands. Miller was granted bail totalling $280,000 on November 17 on charges of simple larceny, malicious damage to property and threatening behaviour following a November 12 confrontation over mining activities. The Guyana Gold and Diamond Miners Association has alleged that villagers threatened workers, seized equipment and wounded two employees. Natural Resources Minister Vickram Bharrat told Kiskadee Watch that the government was not considering suspending mining in the area and described the developments as criminal rather than mining-related.
The APA additionally raised concerns about possible uranium mining on traditional lands in the Middle Mazaruni and the impact of mining in the Marudi Mountains in the Rupununi. It argued that communities could not be expected to trust institutions that failed to protect their territories, collective rights or access to effective remedies.
Turning to the MV Barima tragedy, the association said bereaved families continued to suffer without adequate answers or accountability. It accused the government of seeking to distance itself from responsibility while redress remained slow.
The APA stressed that investments in infrastructure, social services and economic opportunities were obligations of the state and could not substitute for land rights, self-determination, meaningful participation or free, prior and informed consent.
The association, which said it was established 35 years ago to address injustices confronting Indigenous Peoples, urged constitutional bodies, oversight institutions and civil society to uphold accountability regardless of political loyalties.
“Human rights are universal, indivisible, and cannot be selectively applied,” it stated.
Discussion