It should surprise no one that Venezuela is now using leverage with the United States on what both Guyana and Venezuela regard as their most important foreign policy issue. For Guyana, the matter is existential. Venezuela is four times Guyana’s size and claims two-thirds of its territory, 61,000 of our 83,000 square miles, which would add to Venezuela’s existing 352,000. For Venezuela, the aim is to revise a 127-year-old Arbitral Award that it gladly accepted for 63 years before reneging, relying on the flimsy Mallet-Prevost Memorandum of 1944, which alleged that Venezuela was pressured into accepting it. Because the Memorandum lacks substance, Venezuela has shifted its justification over the years. Its most recent argument is that the terms of the 1966 Geneva Agreement substitutes it for the Arbitral Award and requires the now undefined border to be determined through negotiation. As this audacious argument has no merit and does not reflect a scintilla of rationality about the Geneva Agreement, Venezuela instead seeks to pressure the Guyana Government into “negotiating.”
In recent years Guyana has realigned its entire foreign policy in line with the choices of the United States. Ideology may explain part of this, but the growing danger of an imminent Venezuelan incursion into Guyana must also have weighed heavily on the decision. Guyana’s traditional friends, China, Russia and Cuba, were heavily invested in Venezuela and seemed to do nothing to restrain its aggression. They even supplied it with substantial credit, arms and security services. Guyana therefore needed support, and the natural place to find it was the United States, which was no friend of the Venezuelan regime and openly advocated its removal.
Delcy Rodriguez now appears to be fully cooperating with the US takeover of the oil industry and other parts of the Venezuelan economy. It was therefore only a matter of time before she leveraged her new relationship with the US by raising the Guyana-Venezuela border controversy. Anticipating this, I argued in a recent article on Venezuela that Guyana should urge the United States to press the Venezuelan Government to recognize the fact that the ICJ has decided, whenever it does, expecting a ruling in Guyana’s favour. The proposal would have put no pressure on Venezuela to “accept” the decision. But by recognising the fact of the decision would supply Guyana with its own substantial leverage. Guyana was therefore left at the mercy of Venezuela’s own, newly acquired, influence, and its request was apparently placed by the US State Department in the hands of an official who appeared to be totally oblivious of Guyana’s positions. One worrisome consideration is that he may have consulted with his more senior colleagues before going on a considered, approved, expedition to Ms. Rodriguez, with a larger mandate of American firms investing in presumably Venezuela’s Essequibo when he negotiates the transfer of all or part of Essequibo to Venezuela.
The nature of the discourses that the official, Jeremy Lewin, in charge of policy at the State Department for a few months, after serving in the Department of Government Efficiency led by Elon Musk had with Delcy Rodriguez, if true, suggests an abysmal lack of knowledge or sensitivity of the Guyana Border Controversy. Guyana giving up territory? Venezuela having a role in the development of Essequibo? If these are true and Mr. Lewin has been given permission to raise these matters with Venezuela, something is deeply, traumatically, wrong with US policy. It has taken a wrong turn somewhere. This is a slap in the face of Guyana after Marco Rubio’s stirring words in defence of its territorial integrity against Venezuela. It is clear that the Guyana Government cannot allow the matter to rest here. Guyana must know what was discussed and why. If the reports are true, Guyana’s case in all its detail must be repeated to the higher and lower reaches of the Administration so that Guyana’s territory does not become a bargaining chip with Venezuela. It would be interesting to know how high in the State Department Mr. Lewin’s consultations went. If high enough, Guyana’s entire strategy of seeking US’s help against Venezuela, and Marco Rubio’s full throated defence of Guyana’s territorial integrity needs re-examination and re-assessment.
The Guyana Government understands from past history that Venezuela will stop at nothing to pursue its claim over the Essequibo. This pursuit is an industry in Venezuela. It consists of bureaucrats, diplomats, journalists, academics, historians and many other categories of professionals, not excluding the military. The Guyana Government does not have this establishment. But Guyana has seen time and again, and now this past week, how far Venezuela’s reach goes. Delcy Rodriguez did not wake up one morning and decide that she will write the US Government on Guyana. Her decision flows from the vast range of Guyana Venezuela Border experts who work every day to promote Venezuela’s claim. Similarly, Guyana needs the establishment of a permanent body of experts, supported by staff, engaged in fulltime management of the Controversy. This view has been pushed before but it has not yet found favour. Hopefully the shock emanating from Washington will influence decision-making in Guyana.
Discussion