If we thought our western boundary was secure, we were mistaken.
With all the other confusion going on around us in this land of many waters, no one was quite prepared for the border blow emanating from Mr Trump’s White House. There we were, all secure in the knowledge (or so we thought) that the United States government supported our territorial integrity and that at a historical level the ICJ would most likely find the 1899 Award valid, but that peace of mind, it seems, was rooted in certain overly complacent assumptions.
Not where the ICJ is concerned. But what should be recognised is that the world which once set some store by international court decisions is no more, and in any case Venezuela had no intention of recognising the Court’s ruling. For months its media, both opposition and government, has been pressing the Caracas authorities to approach Washington with the argument that no matter what the ICJ found there should be direct border negotiations with Georgetown on the basis of the Geneva Agreement (which they have misread) and given what they erroneously regard as their ‘legitimate’ case.
As it was this campaign was preaching to the already converted, with Reuters reporting that interim President Delcy Rodríguez sent a letter to the US President requesting US mediation to facilitate direct talks with Guyana on the border. She then held a meeting with Policy Chief Jeremy Lewin of the State Department which had been authorised by the White House.
Subsequently the Policy Chief met Foreign Secretary Robert Persaud in Washington and it is the report on that encounter which has left everyone here reeling, because Mr Lewin raised the option of Venezuela taking partial control of Essequibo. He also let it be known that he could help broker territorial talks with Ms Rodríguez.
In Mr Lewin’s exchanges with the interim President the news agency said that he had discussed the possibility of US companies doing business in Essequibo. Presumably that was in areas which it was envisaged Venezuela would control.
For his part Mr Lewin told the news agency that after interim President Rodríguez had sent her letter, “… the White House asked me to conduct preliminary and confidential conversations with the Guyanese and Venezuelans to better dimension the issue for the Administration. I did so and reported back to (Secretary of State Marco Rubio) and White House.”
It is not as if Mr Lewin had the kind of credentials which would qualify him for discussions about our border at any level; he clearly knew absolutely nothing of the issue and had been totally seduced by Venezuela’s fabrications. Sources told Reuters that he had noted in his meeting with Mr Persaud that he had a very close relationship with Ms Rodríguez, not necessarily an indication of a preparedness to listen to the facts of the case.
He was described by Reuters as an “alumnus” of Mr Elon Musk’s Department of Government Efficiency, but he only lasted in his post of policy planning at the State Department for about two months, leaving at the end of October.
Clearly all these discussions were confidential, so it is not as if the government here would have given any account of them to the public in September after they took place. However, after this experience one might have thought they would have been more assiduous about representing Guyana’s case to Guyanese as well as to foreigners. They had no particularly energetic campaign on social media, in the press both locally and abroad, via embassies or at the academic level to counter the barrage of propaganda which Venezuela generates.
It can only be concluded that the reason relates to the fact that the government now feels reassured. Reuters reported that Georgetown had sought responses from different levels of the State Department which had then allayed their fears of a policy change. Yesterday the Ministry of Foreign Affairs issued an insipid release on the subject without even admitting what had been said at the meeting with the Foreign Secretary. It described the focus of that as being, “the pending International Court of Justice (ICJ) ruling, and on reaffirming the United States support on the process.” Well, not quite.
It ended with the statement, “Guyana has received the assurance of the United States Government that nothing has changed since.”
Instead of adopting a passive approach, this country should be taking an active one as Venezuela does, and in addition to the outlets mentioned above, also put its case out in the world’s political arena, writing governments when the occasion arises.
It would be irresponsible of the administration to assume that during the present US presidential term there might not be a change of direction from Washington. The situation has changed dramatically in Venezuela with the extraction of Mr Maduro and the installation of Ms Rodríguez who is very accommodating to the US. President Trump is a transactional president whose interest centres primarily around Venezuelan oil and other minerals such as gold. He has little interest in abstractions such as sovereignty or the complexities of restoring a closed society like Venezuela to the status of an open one.
He is satisfied working with the interim President, and shows no great public interest in institutional reform or democracy. The member of his cabinet who is so interested is Secretary of State Marco Rubio, and he is also the one who has made public statements that the US supported Guyana’s sovereignty and territorial integrity. The problem might come if Mr Rubio goes. The Economist for example has reported that he is looking for employment in the private sector.
Exactly what would happen if someone with less background and a greater Trumpian vision than the current Secretary were to be instated in his post is impossible to say. The problems would grow in Venezuela if the move towards democracy ground to a halt, and that in itself would spell difficulties for us. What recourse would we have either if the White House decided to treat us as an extension of its ‘Venezuela oil and mineral corporation’?
With an ICJ decision in our favour we would have a moral case, but what practical cover would we have?
Anxieties have been expressed about ExxonMobil having signed an MOU with Venezuela, but it is not likely that this means anything much, especially since it has lost so much in that country already and going back would take considerable investment. The MOU does not commit the oil company to anything, and at this stage Guyana is far more important to it than Venezuela. It probably signed it to appease President Trump, but since he has only two years to go the multinational might simply be waiting him out.
Our real danger comes from the west in conjunction with Washington. The Office of the President should not feel easy that the Americans are retraining the Venezuelan military in modern war techniques; Secretary of War Pete Hegseth was there earlier this week. But most of all it should not feel easy about what was said at the September meeting. It should rethink its strategy.
We are not safe.
Discussion