Skip to content
https://kiskadeewatch.com/opinion/guest-columns/from-jagan-to-essequibo-americas-dangerous-game-and-alis-diplomatic-recklessness/
Guest Columns

From Jagan to Essequibo: America’s dangerous game and Ali’s diplomatic recklessness

Christopher Ram

Business and Economic Commentary by Christopher Ram

Political incompetence and diplomatic misjudgment have brought Guyana’s sovereignty under renewed threat. Reuters’ disclosure that Trump administration officials floated the possibility of Venezuela acquiring part of Essequibo exposes the danger of President Irfaan Ali’s personal embrace of Washington. What passes for diplomacy may be a Trojan horse carrying the prospect of surrendering Guyanese territory.

According to Reuters, Jeremy Lewin, a State Department official and adviser to Secretary of State Marco Rubio, raised the possibility with Foreign Secretary Robert Persaud. Lewin claimed White House authorisation and reported to Rubio, who received red-carpet treatment in Guyana. Ali must demand an explanation from Rubio and make clear that Guyana’s territorial integrity is not open to negotiation with anyone, including the United States.

The Ministry of Foreign Affairs assures us that American policy has not changed. That is not the issue. It is whether Guyana’s policy has changed. The 1899 Arbitral Award settled the boundary; the controversy is now before the International Court of Justice (ICJ). No parallel bargain over territory should be entertained.

Guyana has reason to distrust American intentions. Venezuela revived its challenge to the 1899 Arbitral Award in 1962, when Washington and London were conspiring to prevent Dr Cheddi Jagan from governing an independent Guyana. Following American military intervention, Maduro’s removal and the emergence of a Venezuelan leadership subservient to Washington, American influence in Venezuela has expanded dramatically. Its strategic and petroleum interests may now be greater than they were sixty years ago. Fear of communism in Guyana has given way to control of Venezuela’s vast petroleum reserves, making Guyana expendable in the great-power calculation.

Our history also counsels against romanticising Guyana’s own leaders. Forbes Burnham, eager to lead an independent country, concluded and signed the Geneva Agreement in February 1966. In my view, that ill-advised decision gave Venezuela’s challenge renewed diplomatic life. Burnham’s political ambitions must be considered alongside the Agreement’s lasting consequences. Guyanese diplomats, including Rashleigh Jackson, subsequently worked for decades to defend our territorial integrity. Historian and diplomat Cedric Joseph’s research into Anglo-American involvement in reopening the controversy offers a warning against dependence on Washington. Ali appears to have disregarded these hard-earned lessons.

His course began with the December 2023 meeting with Nicolás Maduro in St Vincent, which gave Maduro a diplomatic platform amid threats to Guyana’s sovereignty. Then came the embrace of Washington: photographs with Trump, engagements involving senior PPP figures and Mike Pompeo, Rubio’s visit, and appearances aboard an American warship. What was discussed or promised? Diplomacy is not measured by photographs with powerful men.

Nor can responsibility rest with Ali alone. Guyana stood largely idle while he drew the country into Trump’s orbit, mistaking access to Washington for security. That was a fundamental mistake. With domestic political constraints following the recent mid-term elections, Trump may seek deals abroad; his approach to Ukraine and Putin illustrates the danger that smaller countries’ interests can be subordinated to bargains among powerful states. Essequibo must not become a bargaining chip in Washington’s pursuit of influence and petroleum arrangements with Venezuela.

After the Reuters disclosure, the US Embassy reaffirmed support for the 1899 Award but added that the boundary should be respected unless changed by a competent legal body ‘or with the consent of both parties.’ Washington could recognise the existing boundary while encouraging Guyana to consent to another. That is the Trojan horse.

Ali must account for the September meeting between Persaud and Lewin. Foreign Minister Hugh Todd says minutes exist and that Persaud rejected negotiations. The Government should disclose those minutes, subject to demonstrable diplomatic confidentiality, and explain why Persaud rather than Todd handled the engagement, who authorised it, and whether the President and Border Committee were informed. The authority of the Foreign Secretary’s office also warrants scrutiny.

Ali should arrange an extraordinary sitting of the National Assembly next week and explain what transpired. He must affirm that Guyana will not negotiate away territory, will abide by the ICJ’s judgment, and expects Washington and Caracas to respect its sovereignty.

Parliament should adopt a unanimous resolution; the President should consult the Opposition, Border Committee, CARICOM and international partners. Guyana’s sovereignty must rest on national unity and international law, not any foreign power’s goodwill.

We must settle for nothing less than One Guyana, not a dismembered country, making this a sovereignty matter, not a personal, partisan or electoral affair.

You reached the end of this article without encountering a paywall.

That is deliberate. We believe reliable journalism about Guyana should be available to everyone from the hinterland to the coast, including those who cannot afford to pay for it. But investigating, reporting and publishing every story takes time, energy and resources. Keeping our journalism open depends on the commitment of readers who can chip in and contribute to help cover the cost for everyone.

Please join the Kiskadee family by taking a subscription. Every contribution counts to our commitment to our journalists, to our readers, and to independent, public-interest journalism.

And please spread the word. One one dutty build dam!

Become a supporter