Skip to content
https://kiskadeewatch.com/world/caribbean/caribbean-heads-of-judiciary-condemn-antigua-pms-remark-on-foreign-judges/
Caribbean

Caribbean Heads of Judiciary condemn Antigua PM’s remark on foreign judges

Gaston Browne

Caribbean heads of judiciary yesterday condemned as “unproductive and dangerous” remarks by Antigua and Barbuda Prime Minister Gaston Browne suggesting that foreign judges could be removed from the country over allegedly lenient sentencing.

In a joint statement, the judicial heads said they noted with “deep and unsettling concern” Browne’s comments on Monday.

The statement said Browne, apparently dissatisfied with sentences imposed in criminal cases, had referred without naming the person to a “particular judge” whom he considered to have “a propensity to give criminals a break”.

It said the Prime Minister went further by suggesting that if the judge could not “follow the lead of the parliament to give longer sentences”, the person should leave Antigua and Barbuda voluntarily or be deported and declared persona non grata.

“We strongly condemn these unfortunate remarks made by the Hon. Gaston Browne against the judge and, by extension, the judiciary of the Eastern Caribbean region,” the heads of judiciary said.

They warned that the comments threatened judicial independence and could weaken the separation of powers among the judiciary, executive and legislature.

“Mutual respect for the constitutional boundaries between the three co-equal arms of the state—the Judiciary, the Executive and the Legislature—is an indispensable necessity for the effective and just preservation of the rule of law and the integrity of our democratic institutions,” the statement said.

The judicial heads said the lawful mechanism for challenging an unduly lenient sentence was to provide the prosecution with a right of appeal to the Court of Appeal and ultimately either the Caribbean Court of Justice or the Judicial Committee of the Privy Council.

“This is the only lawful and legitimate manner consistent with the rule of law and the separation of powers for the issue to be resolved,” they said.

They acknowledged that robust public discussion and legitimate criticism were important features of a democratic society but said such criticism must be respectful and directed towards constructive engagement.

The judiciary, they added, would continue to discharge its constitutional functions “impartially, independently and without fear or favour”.

In a post on his Facebook page on Monday, Browne said Parliament had increased the maximum sentence for gun crimes to 15 years after being advised by members of the judiciary not to legislate minimum sentences, as this would restrict judicial discretion and trespass on the judiciary’s domain.

However, he alleged that some judicial officers were abusing that discretion by imposing lenient sentences on repeat offenders and persons convicted of serious crimes.

“These short sentences have now resulted in approximately 250 repeat offenders, who are stretching law enforcement capabilities and putting the entire society at risk,” Browne said.

He asserted that the executive had the authority to seek the removal of underperforming members of the judiciary from the jurisdiction.

“Alternatively, if the court refuses to remove them from the jurisdiction and they are non-belongers—should the Executive exercise its right to remove them from the state in the interest of national security and protection of the citizenry from these criminals?” he asked, while inviting public views.

In a subsequent comment under the post, Browne acknowledged that threatening deportation could discourage foreign judicial officers from serving in Antigua and Barbuda.

“The most significant drawback I see is that foreign members of the judiciary may become afraid to serve in the jurisdiction for the fear of deportation,” he said.

He added that greater cooperation between the judiciary and Parliament was therefore the “only viable option”.

“When the parliament asks for increased sentences, the judiciary has a duty to oblige, failing which they will be trespassing on the domain of the parliament,” Browne said.

You reached the end of this article without encountering a paywall.

That is deliberate. We believe reliable journalism about Guyana should be available to everyone from the hinterland to the coast, including those who cannot afford to pay for it. But investigating, reporting and publishing every story takes time, energy and resources. Keeping our journalism open depends on the commitment of readers who can chip in and contribute to help cover the cost for everyone.

Please join the Kiskadee family by taking a subscription. Every contribution counts to our commitment to our journalists, to our readers, and to independent, public-interest journalism.

And please spread the word. One one dutty build dam!

Become a supporter