Business and Economic Commentary by Christopher Ram
Introduction
The Public Accounts Committee, the National Assembly’s financial oversight body, has agreed to examine the Auditor General’s reports for 2020 to 2024 together, “side by side”. That would be welcome news, except that for five years the Committee could hardly find time to meet. I suspect the decision is driven by the Government’s wish for bragging rights: to declare the backlog cleared. A failure of scrutiny will have been converted into a claim of completion.
PAC Chairman Vishnu Panday told the Assembly the Committee met just 26 times in five years, because Government members stayed away. In September he called combining 2020–2024 virtually impossible without sacrificing scrutiny. Yet he accepted it. Under the Government’s own 2022 quorum rule, two members from each side must be present; an Opposition walkout would have stopped the vote.
In 2022, Minister Juan Edghill opposed combining just 2019 and 2020 because they needed diligent scrutiny. Now five years are too old to bother with, and members too busy to attend will multiply their attendance to secure those bragging rights. The ability of this Government to speak from three sides of its mouth is a unique medical feat.
Five years cannot be done at once
The PAC took 27 months and 50 hearings to examine 2010 and 2011, when the budgets were $142.8 billion and $161.4 billion – $304 billion in all. The budgets for 2021 to 2024 alone came to about $2.86 trillion, more than nine times as much. Now the Committee proposes to examine five such years in one sweep. That is financial madness.
Former Auditor General Anand Goolsarran has advised against it. He counts eight attempts since 1992 to clear arrears by combining years; all failed. The Auditor General’s reports for 2022, 2023 and 2024 alone carry 565 recommendations, each calling an accounting officer to answer, many since moved on. At the old pace, five years would need about 125 hearings, against 26 meetings in the past five years.
A real examination asks what changed, whether the law was followed, and what the concerns are. Take concessions: about $1.06 trillion over 2020–2024 on the Auditor General’s figures. The reports never say who got them, or under what authority. A list is not an audit – it is hardly anything. The figures do not even add up: oil and gas exemptions go from $108 billion in 2022 to $196.6 million in 2023 and back to $95 billion, without comment.
Omissions
The PAC examines the reports placed before it. If they are deficient, no review can repair them. A properly advised Auditor General cannot plead lack of power: the Audit Act gives him complete discretion. My fear is that the Chairman will be bullied into confining the Committee to what the reports contain, and to refrain from anything not included. Let us consider what the reports leave out.
Start with concessions. Section 38 of the Investment Act requires the Auditor General to audit them annually. In twenty-two years, no report has been laid. I have sent the Auditor General, Deodat Sharma, a pre-action letter. He is unlikely to lose sleep: the Audit Office’s matrimonial relationship with the Government (more below) protects him.
Then there is Silica City – Pradoville 3 – developed through CH&PA on State land with a US$100 million Saudi loan. It is not mentioned in the 2022, 2023 or 2024 reports. Nor is CH&PA’s failure to complete an annual report on its operations.
Then there are the bodies that do not account. In 2024 the Ministry of Agriculture and the Office of the President alone transferred $73.7 billion to bodies in breach of section 80 of the Fiscal Management and Accountability Act. The NDIA was last audited for 2016, the National Parks Commission for 2008. GO-Invest, through which the concessions flow, has submitted nothing since 2020. The Auditor General’s annual remedy: “continue to follow-up”. The money continues to flow.
Worse still are the constitutional bodies. Their funds are a direct charge on the Consolidated Fund and spared line-by-line scrutiny. Their audits should be held to a higher standard than those of statutory bodies, whose audited accounts must be tabled separately. Instead, the 2024 report lists thirteen of the sixteen in one table, each “Unqualified”, with no findings. Not one of those statements or opinions has been laid; for the public they do not exist. GECOM, which spent about $18.7 billion in 2021–2025, is not listed at all. The Parliament Office is one more line in the table – for an Assembly that hibernates for months, and in which no report under the Access to Information Act has been tabled since 2011.
Capacity and competence
Special audits are permitted by the Act, yet his reports list them by title only. Five shown as in progress in 2023 vanish from the 2024 report. The subjects are town councils, tree porcupines, chicken and eggs. There is nothing on a major contract, oil, the NIS or Silica City.
The Audit Office is comfortable with minor details and untroubled by consequential numbers – much like the audit of costs under the 2016 Petroleum Agreement. Five deficient reports reviewed side by side will be the same farce in a different room.
Not one of the PAC’s nine members is a professional accountant or auditor. Some Government appointees are known for creative embellishments of the truth. The Committee’s resource person, the Auditor General, is not a professionally qualified accountant either. Yet his tenure has been extended beyond retirement age, which pleases him and other key players. In my view, the extension masks an awkward fact: the Director of Audit, and de facto Auditor General, is Mrs Gitanjali Singh, wife of the Minister responsible for Finance. Her formal succession would put her at the head of the office that audits all the financial transactions for which her husband has portfolio responsibility.
Conclusion
The Committee is committed to its course. If it must take five years together, it should do so competently and honestly. Under section 45 of the Audit Act, it should require the Auditor General to report on what his reports omit: Silica City, CH&PA, GECOM and the unaudited bodies. It should demand the section 38 audit of concessions, every special audit report of the past five years, and a separate audit report, laid in the Assembly, for each constitutional body. And it should meet weekly, under a quorum rule no side can abuse.
Decades ago, Clive Thomas, perhaps the best economist Guyana has ever produced, called for a body independent of the executive to support the Assembly’s scrutiny of the public finances. It was promised in 2015 and never established. Five years of oil budgets make the case urgent.
A backlog is not cleared by declaring it cleared. A Committee that barely meets, an Auditor General who lists rather than examines, an oil audit that never ends: it would be a comedy show if public moneys were not involved.
To the Opposition members: do not join this charade. If the Committee produces a report that pretends to an examination that never took place, issue a Minority Report saying so.
Discussion