Acting Director of Prisons Nicklon Elliot has told the High Court that Opposition Leader Azruddin Mohamed is being held alone in a seven-by-14-foot cell at the Lusignan Prison under rules for high-profile prisoners.
He denied that Mohamed had been placed in solitary confinement and said prison records showed that on November 1 he spent about nine hours and 20 minutes outside his holding area.
In an affidavit filed yesterday on behalf of Attorney General Anil Nandlall SC, Elliot said Mohamed was classified as a high-profile prisoner when he was admitted on October 30. He said the assessment took into account the nature of the charge, public interest in the case and security risks to others, including prison staff and inmates. He said the restrictions on Mohamed’s accommodation, movement and visits were imposed for security.
“I hereby emphatically reject those allegations,” Elliot said of the claims of solitary confinement. He said the prison had designated cells for solitary confinement as a disciplinary sanction and that Mohamed had never been sanctioned or placed in one of those cells.
The affidavit was filed ahead of tomorrow’s hearing of the challenge to Magistrate Abigail Gibbs’ refusal of bail. Mohamed and Police Constable Ryan Greene have been on remand since October 30, when they pleaded not guilty to a joint cybercrime charge involving the alleged unauthorised sharing of surveillance footage of the October 12 shooting outside the Kitty home of Police Special Branch Head, Senior Superintendent Prem Narine.
Mohamed’s family have alleged he was being held in isolation, exposed to extreme heat and fumes from a nearby dumpsite, and kept under artificial lighting for about 23 hours a day. Justice Priscilla Chandra-Hanif raised concerns about the reported lighting and said Mohamed should not be held in oppressive conditions.
Elliot said Mohamed occupies a prefabricated cell on the upper floor of Building Five, which was constructed about two years ago. He said the cell was designed to provide adequate ventilation, lighting and sanitation and that the light was part of the building’s original system. He denied that it was installed or maintained to cause discomfort or deprive Mohamed of sleep. The affidavit does not specify how many hours a day the light was on.
Elliot also disputed the allegation that smoke and fumes from the dumpsite were reaching Mohamed. He said the site was several thousand feet south of the building and that the prevailing wind generally blew away from it. A Prison Service statement attached to the affidavit said officials adjusted the fan serving Mohamed’s cell area after he requested it.
Elliot cited records for October 31 and November 1 showing visits from relatives and lawyers. He said Mohamed spent about nine hours and 20 minutes outside his holding area on November 1, including a 90-minute welfare counselling session and a two-hour visit from one of his lawyers. He said Mohamed was also allowed three calls to relatives that day and was given reading and writing materials. His family was permitted to supply his daily meals, and additional visits were approved about a week after his admission, Elliot said.
Elliot attached a copy of Prison Service Standing Order No. 38, which says high-profile prisoners must be escorted to a visiting booth and receive visits in the presence and hearing of the escorting officers. The order also provides for 30 to 60 minutes of exercise, depending on the prisoner’s conduct and the discretion of the officer in charge. The affidavit does not say how much exercise Mohamed received.
Justice Chandra-Hanif refused interim bail on Friday but brought the substantive hearing forward from November 23 to November 17. The judge made no findings on the disputed prison conditions and said those allegations concerned events after Magistrate Gibbs’ ruling. The issue before the court is whether Magistrate Gibbs acted lawfully, rationally and fairly when she refused bail on the information before her on October 30. The hearing was scheduled for 9 am, with a written decision expected at 3 pm.
Discussion