-High Court reserves ruling until tomorrow after over five hours of arguments
Opposition Leader Azruddin Mohamed remained behind bars today after more than five hours of legal arguments from both sides failed to produce a decision on his challenge to Magistrate Abigail Gibbs’ refusal to grant him bail.
Justice Priscilla Chandra-Hanif reserved her ruling until Wednesday, November 18, at 11 a.m., following lengthy submissions from Mohamed’s attorneys and the State. She was originally to make a decision today.
Proceedings commenced at 9 a.m., with both sides presenting arguments in the substantive judicial review application challenging Magistrate Gibbs’ October 30 decision to refuse Mohamed bail and remand him to prison.
Today’s hearing followed the High Court’s decision last Friday to refuse Mohamed interim bail while expediting the substantive challenge.
The Court had initially scheduled the substantive hearing for November 23, with judgment expected on November 24. However, Justice Chandra-Hanif brought the proceedings forward in recognition of the urgency surrounding Mohamed’s continued detention.
A ruling had originally been scheduled for 3 p.m. today, but following more than five hours of arguments, the Judge set aside Wednesday morning to deliver her decision.
At the centre of the proceedings was whether Magistrate Gibbs had acted lawfully, rationally and fairly when she refused Mohamed bail.
Mohamed’s legal team, led by Senior Counsel Roysdale Forde, had challenged the legality of the Magistrate’s decision, while the State, represented by Attorney General Anil Nandlall SC and other counsel, opposed the relief sought.
In her earlier ruling, Justice Chandra-Hanif made it clear that refusing interim bail did not determine the merits of Mohamed’s substantive challenge or establish that the Magistrate’s decision was lawful.
Mohamed has remained in custody since October 30 in connection with a cybercrime charge arising from the alleged unauthorised obtaining and disclosure of police surveillance footage linked to the October 12 shooting incident outside the Kitty residence of Senior Superintendent Prem Narine.
Discussion