Britain cannot walk away from an inherited liability, and we cannot afford to receive one carelessly.
By C. Justin Robinson
C. Justin Robinson is Pro Vice Chancellor and Campus Principal, UWI Five Islands Campus
On the eve of CHOGM 2026 in Antigua and Barbuda, British Prime Minister Andy Burnham said he was “open” to a formal apology for slavery. He also wrote, “I do not think that British people today can be held liable for historical wrongs, however heinous, that happened in a different age under different laws and in which they played no personal part.” Writing in the Guardian he ruled out financial reparations for the crime of slavery.
The notion that liabilities or financial obligations expire when the people who incurred them die is out of step with established financial norms. The owners and management of a going concern like a corporation or a state inherit the assets and liabilities of previous owners and managers unless there is some explicit exception. Normal financial practice is that when one bank, for example, acquires another, it takes on the loan book and the lawsuits, and similarly when a new government is sworn in, it is obligated to service the bonds its opponents issued.
Surely, many if not most of the current shareholders of a company receive dividends from company decisions taken 100 years ago, and similarly the company is obliged to service historical claims against the firm. I am intrigued by the argument that you get to keep the inheritance and disclaim the debt.
The British state would appear to be the epitome of a going concern as the same Crown, the same Treasury, the same Parliament, in unbroken continuity since the age of slavery. The matter of an outstanding liability of the British state is a fundamentally different issue from the question of whether today’s Britons are personally guilty of the events that led to the liability.
The Prime Minister’s argument gets more intriguing when one looks at the financial events surrounding the ending of slavery in the British West Indies. In 1835 the British government borrowed some of the funds to pay £20 million in compensation to slave owners for the loss of their “property.” That debt was rolled over into the government’s gilt programme and ended up in an undated bond, the 4% Consolidated Loan, which was finally redeemed on 1 February 2015. Therefore, British taxpayers alive today, including descendants of the former enslaved persons, who played no personal part in slavery, were servicing a slavery-era obligation within the last decade. However much of the principal survived to 2015 is beside the point as the obligation was refinanced and not written off.
Some may argue that sovereign liability is not identical to corporate liability, but the relevant point is that the British Treasury itself carried this slavery-era obligation until 2015.
So, the principle that today’s citizens cannot carry the obligations of a past age is not, in fact, British practice. I am tempted to rest my case here, but I find it difficult to ignore the concerns in my beloved Caribbean. Accounting is based on double entry hence the ledger runs both ways, and the second half of this argument is addressed to us.
One of the lessons of the emancipation from slavery in the 1830s is what happens when compensation is designed by and for the powerful. In that case the monetary compensation went to the slave owners and not to those who suffered the ravages of slavery. No official document captures the moral and material failure of that decision better than a report commissioned by the enduring and self-correcting British state. The state appointed, West India Royal Commission delivered what has become known as the Moyne Commission report documenting the abject poverty and despair of conditions among the descendants of the freed, but uncompensated slaves in the British West Indies, a century after emancipation.
To avoid a repeat of compensation designed by and for the powerful I urge governments to provide assurances and structures to ensure that if reparations come, in whatever form, there are guarantees that they will not disappear into consolidated funds, contracts for the well-connected and budgets spent and forgotten within an electoral cycle.
My submission is that the sanctity of the reparations movement will be preserved if it is legislated that any reparatory transfers will be held in ring-fenced, independently governed trusts, national or regional and not absorbed into general revenue. Those trusts should be invested on endowment principles where the principal is preserved and there are published spending rules to ensure that the benefits reach generations to come. The spending priorities identified in CARICOM’s Ten-Point Plan, such as health, education, technology and cultural restitution are the right priorities.
Plantation slavery in the British West Indies was defined by an attempt at cultural erasure evidenced by the deliberate stripping of their African heritage from the slaves, their names, their languages and their faiths. Ironically culture is the one asset slavery failed to erase, and it was kept alive by drummers, calypsonians and Rastafari, often against the state, including our own. These custodians of our cultural heritage define the Caribbean brand, drive our festivals and fill our hotels, yet many struggle to live decent lives and retire without pensions. When King Austin, whose song Progress is viewed as one of the best calypsos of all time, died in 2016, the then President of Trinidad and Tobago, Anthony Carmona, said, “My deepest regret is that this great calypsonian, King Austin, like many before, died in a type of destitution that must make us all feel a sense of shame.”
In finance, custodians are paid and reparatory justice should provide income support, health and retirement benefits for cultural custodians. It would be a custodial fee, long overdue, and part of it is owed by us. The ledger runs both ways here too.
Britain’s position appears to rest on a separation between the people of today and the state of yesterday, but Finance principles do not recognize that separation, and neither, until 2015, did the British Treasury. What is now required is a statement from the British government committing to engage CARICOM’s Reparations Commission by a named date and for CARICOM nations to pass the legislation on a transparent framework for the management and disbursement of any reparations funds. The ledger runs both ways.
Discussion