By Dr Bertrand Ramcharan
Seventh Chancellor of the University of Guyana
I write this with some reluctance. The Government of Guyana has a sensitive issue to deal with and it needs support, as well as space to manage the situation. These comments are meant to facilitate that process. In a word, this is a situation to be handled with quiet diplomacy.
The immediate problem at hand is the disclosure that US officials in high places have been talking to both Venezuelan and Guyanese leaders about the possibilities of a negotiated solution to the border problem. The idea floated of a Guyanese concession of territory in the Essequibo is a naturally unpalatable one and has drawn alarm in the Guyanese media. This is an understandable expression of patriotism.
The statement issued by the US Embassy in Georgetown has drawn adverse comments from Guyanese. But calm analysis would suggest that the statement, though problematic, was an understandable one from the Embassy’s perspective. The White House and the State Department have apparently been probing with Guyana and Venezuela the possibilities of a negotiated solution. The US Embassy had to have a nuanced statement covering all ground: indicating support for Guyana’s position on a solution before the ICJ; being mindful of America’s new relationship with Venezuela; and attentive to the fact that the White House has a penchant for efforts to broker negotiated solutions – with the President’s quest for a Nobel Peace Prize taken into account.
One should therefore be sober-minded about the US Embassy statement – as indeed about the whole episode of the US President and Secretary of State apparently seeking to juggle US interests towards Venezuela and Guyana.
What is important to keep in mind is that Guyana’s case is still before the ICJ and a decision will be handed down in the next year. Guyana’s interest in an adjudicated solution before the ICJ is thus preserved. A quiet approach is best here.
Discussion