For when at length I come to die,
I want no gilded tomb,
Just let me rest within thy breast,
Where thy sweet flowers bloom.
Extract of the Guyana patriotic song “My Native Land”
When I was growing up, I loved to listen to and participate in the singing of the National Anthem and Guyana’s patriotic songs as well as in the recital of Pledge. Whenever “My Native Land” was being sung, the hair in my body stood on end and a cold shivering passed through my entire body. I also recall my primary school days when every Monday morning my headmaster would indulge us in a session of moral education. One of his statements that struck me to this day is: ‘What thou does’t in the closet shall be set forth on the rooftop’. Now, where are these patriotic songs and why are they not being sung? We may very well need them in the light of recent developments on the border controversy with our western neighbour. And is moral education being taught in school at the moment? A nation devoid of morals and ethics sits on the edge of the precipice!
In today’s article, we begin a discussion of the 2025 Auditor General’s report on the audit of the public accounts and the accounts of Ministries/Departments and Regions. The report was recently laid in the National Assembly and referred to the Public Accounts Committee(PAC) from detailed scrutiny. Unfortunately, the PAC has seven years of backlogged accounts to examine and report on. With the Committee’s recent decision to combine an unprecedented five years in its examination, it is unclear when the examination of the 2025 public accounts will begin. Suffice to state that by the time the PAC gets around to scrutinise the latter, it may be too late to take the necessary corrective actions, given the passage of time and the unavailability of many accounting officers to provide answerability for the various discrepancies and shortcomings identified in the report.
Since 1992, the PAC had made eight attempts to combine the number years together in the hope of bringing the backlogged examination up to date. However, the effort proved unsuccessful primarily due to political considerations taking precedence over the public good and the public interest. The change in the quorum size in 2022 for holding meetings of the Committee made matters worse as government members in many instances did not make themselves available, thereby stymieing the work of the PAC. Several stakeholders have expressed the view that these postponements due to a lack of a quorum were a deliberate attempt to delay as long as possible the Committee’s scrutiny of the public accounts from 2020 onwards.
Size of the report
The 2025 Auditor General’s report contains 200 pages of narrative, 433 paragraphs and 111 recommendations. In contrast, his 2019 report was 523 pages long, with 1,518 paragraphs and 645 recommendations. This was despite the fact that the total expenditure in 2025 had increased from $291.592 billion in 2019 to $1.344 trillion, a more than four-and one half fold increase. Additionally, capital expenditure, especially as regards infrastructure development works, increased ten-fold from $66.262 billion in 2019 to $684.897 billion in 2025.
Given the scale of expenditure in 2025, one would have expected the Auditor General’s report to be significantly larger with a greater number of findings and recommendations, compared with 2019. This is especially so since there have been no public financial management initiatives aimed at improving systems and procedures though the implementation of internationally recognised accounting standards, and the upgrade of applicable laws, regulations and circular instructions. In addition, there was no dedicated effort to enhance internal audit capacity at the various Ministries/Departments/Regions, which would eased the workload of the Audit Office.
As indicated in last week’s article, during 2015-2019, several initiatives were undertaken to improve our financial management systems that saw a 12-point improvement in Guyana’s assessment on the Corruption Perceptions Index. These initiatives need not be repeated. A Budget Transparency Action Plan (BTAP) was also designed and approved in 2015, and implementation began with effect from 2016. BTAP, which can be found at the Ministry of Finance’s website, contains 14 action items, with a timetable for full implementation. Unfortunately, the political situation following the December 2018 vote of no confidence in the Government adversely affected full implementation. Included in the BTAP are the following:
(a) Advancing the accountability timeframe from budget preparation and approval to the PAC examination of and reporting on the public accounts. In this way, the entire accountability cycle can be completed within 12 months of the close of the fiscal year.
(b) Approval of the National Budget before the beginning of the fiscal year in question. In this regard, we must note that the Estimates for the years 2017, 2018 and 2019 were presented and approved by the Assembly before the beginning of the respective fiscal years.
(c) Preparation of comprehensive procurement plans in support of the Budget, a more timely and detailed Mid-Year report, and an End-of-Year report on the results of the execution of the Budget.
Additionally, the Government had approved the implementation of International Public Sector Accounting Standards (IPSAS) in an attempt to replace the cash-based system of accounting. Work had begun in its phased implementation in 2016. However, the effort appeared to have been abandoned. As a result, the outdated and outmoded cash-based system, with all its deficiencies, shortcomings, manipulation and abuse, continues to be used to record and report the Government’s financial transactions. In 2004, the Integrated Financial Management System (IFMAS) was introduced. However, to date, two important modules – Purchasing; and Asset and Inventory – are yet to be implemented. In 2016, the Ministry of Finance initiated an upgrade IFMAS to IFMIS (Integrated Management Information System).
Auditor General’s comments on the Office of the President, Office of the Prime Minister and the Ministry of Finance
The Office of the President incurred expenditure totalling $11.996 billion in 2025 in respect of its six programmes. Compare this with 2019 where approximately the same amount was expended on ten programmes. The Auditor General’s comments as regards the latter are contained in 88 paragraphs with recommendations amounting to 43. Fast forward to 2025, his comments are reflected in only three paragraphs, and there was only one recommendation! One must also bear in mind that under that Office’s capital expenditure programme, there were 18 projects but there was no commentary on any one of them. A similar situation existed in respect of 2024 where again there were only three paragraphs with the same one recommendation!
It has been the practice for the Audit Office since 1992 to examine each project and to report the results, whether they reflect findings and recommendations or not. In this way, legislators and the public at large are apprised of how funds approved by the Assembly have been expended. What could have accounted for this sharp decline in the number of findings and recommendations as they relate to the Office of the President, only the Auditor General can explain.
In one of the three paragraphs under the Office of the President, the Auditor General referred to status of financial reporting and audit of eight agencies in receipt of a subvention under that Office. These entities are in arrears in having audited accounts, ranging from one year in the case of the Environmental Protection Agency to 13 years in the case of the National Parks Commission. However, the Audit Office had in its possession 34 sets of draft financial statements for these entities waiting to be audited and reported on. A similar situation existed in respect of the 12 agencies under the Office of the Prime Minister where there were 41 sets of draft financial statements with the Audit Office. It is not clear how long these statements have been with the Audit Office.
As regards the Office of the Prime Minister, there was only one recommendation in relation to financial reporting and audit of the 12 entities referred to above; while for 17 capital expenditure projects in 2025, only the Gas-to-Power project was commented on in six innocuous paragraphs. In the case of the Ministry of Finance, there were 27 paragraphs covering mainly the Lotto funds, IFMIS, operations of the Tender Board and the Public Procurement Commission. Most of the contents were a repeat of previous years’ comments. The Auditor General made only three recommendations. The nine projects under the Ministry’s capital expenditure programme did not attract any comment from the Auditor General.
Next week, we will continue our discussion on the 2025 Auditor General’s report.
Discussion