Skip to content
https://kiskadeewatch.com/guyana/judge-says-magistrate-was-entitled-to-consider-risk-of-offences-in-refusing-bail-to-mohamed/

Judge says Magistrate was entitled to consider risk of offences in refusing bail to Mohamed

Opposition Leader Azruddin Mohamed will remain behind bars after the High Court yesterday dismissed a judicial review application challenging a Magistrate’s decision to refuse him bail, ruling that the existence of other pending criminal charges and allegations of interference with the administration of justice could legitimately be considered when assessing the risk of offending.

In a 53-page judgment, Justice Priscilla Chandra-Hanif rejected the application filed by Mohamed’s mother, Bonita Mohamed, seeking to overturn Magistrate Abigail Gibbs’ October 30, 2026 decision denying him bail in connection with a cybercrime charge.

The Judge found that the applicant had failed to establish the grounds necessary for the High Court to interfere with the Magistrate’s exercise of her statutory discretion.

“Accordingly, this court DISMISSES this Fixed Date Application filed on 2nd November, 2026 for an order of certiorari to quash the decision of the First Respondent dated 30th October, 2026 refusing to admit Azruddin Mohamed to bail,” the ruling stated.

The decision means Mohamed, who has been detained at the Lusignan Prison since October 30, remains in custody.

Central to the legal challenge was whether the Magistrate had sufficient grounds under Section 7 of the Bail Act 2022 to conclude that Mohamed was likely to commit another offence if released.

His attorneys, led by Senior Counsel Roysdale Forde and Siand Dhurjon, argued that the prosecution had failed to establish a proper evidential foundation for refusing bail. They maintained that pending charges, without convictions or breaches of existing bail conditions, could not establish a likelihood of further offending.

The defence also relied on Mohamed’s previous grants of bail in separate proceedings and his compliance with those conditions.

However, Justice Chandra-Hanif rejected the proposition that a history of convictions or demonstrated criminal behaviour was an essential prerequisite for refusing bail.

She said that although outstanding charges could not be treated as proof of guilt, the circumstances surrounding those allegations could be considered collectively where they were relevant to a properly supported assessment of future risk.

The Judge placed particular emphasis on the prosecution’s allegations concerning possible witness intimidation, obstruction of justice and the handling of police surveillance footage connected to other criminal proceedings involving Mohamed.

The prosecution had argued before the Magistrate that the various allegations demonstrated a concerning pattern of conduct, including possible interference with witnesses and ongoing investigations.

Importantly, the High Court observed that Mohamed’s own attorneys had introduced detailed information about his other pending criminal proceedings during the original bail hearing in an attempt to demonstrate weaknesses in the cybercrime charge.

Justice Chandra-Hanif reasoned that having invited the Magistrate to examine those proceedings, the defence could not subsequently argue that the Magistrate was prohibited from considering the same circumstances when assessing the prosecution’s objections to bail.

Nevertheless, the judge stressed that this did not mean the defence had conceded the truth of the allegations or waived Mohamed’s constitutional rights.

The Court also determined that prosecutors were not required to call witnesses or present sworn testimony in every preliminary bail hearing before a Magistrate could lawfully refuse bail.

Instead, the Magistrate was required to have a rational and sufficiently grounded basis for concluding that a statutory risk existed. Unsupported allegations alone would not justify detention.

On the question of Mohamed’s previous compliance with bail conditions, the Judge acknowledged that this was an important factor in his favour but found that it did not automatically eliminate concerns arising from subsequently instituted criminal proceedings.

The judgment also addressed allegations of bias against Magistrate Gibbs. Justice Chandra-Hanif found that the material before the Court did not establish a sufficient foundation for that challenge.

She further examined the Magistrate’s original case jacket and subsequent written memorandum explaining her refusal of bail, concluding that the memorandum was consistent with the reasons originally recorded and did not introduce new grounds to justify the decision retrospectively.

Another significant aspect of the ruling concerned the limits of judicial review.

Justice Chandra-Hanif explained that the High Court was not conducting a fresh bail hearing or deciding whether it would have reached the same conclusion as the Magistrate.

Rather, its responsibility was to determine whether the original decision was lawful, rational and consistent with the Bail Act.

The Judge noted that subsequent developments which were not before the Magistrate on October 30 could not be used to establish that her original decision was unlawful. Such matters could instead be pursued through a fresh bail application or other appropriate legal proceedings.

Despite dismissing the challenge, Justice Chandra-Hanif emphasised that the ruling did not amount to a finding that Mohamed was guilty of any of the offences with which he has been charged.

She also stressed that the constitutional rights to personal liberty and the presumption of innocence remained applicable to every accused person, regardless of political office.

In concluding, the Judge addressed the considerable political attention surrounding the proceedings, maintaining that the Court had not been influenced by public controversy.

She cautioned against portraying judicial decisions through partisan narratives and urged the media, legal representatives and the public to report and interpret the judgment accurately.

Mohamed’s substantive criminal proceedings remain separate from Wednesday’s judicial review ruling, which leaves the Magistrate’s October 30 refusal of bail undisturbed.

You reached the end of this article without encountering a paywall.

That is deliberate. We believe reliable journalism about Guyana should be available to everyone from the hinterland to the coast, including those who cannot afford to pay for it. But investigating, reporting and publishing every story takes time, energy and resources. Keeping our journalism open depends on the commitment of readers who can chip in and contribute to help cover the cost for everyone.

Please join the Kiskadee family by taking a subscription. Every contribution counts to our commitment to our journalists, to our readers, and to independent, public-interest journalism.

And please spread the word. One one dutty build dam!

Become a supporter