Speaker of the National Assembly Manzoor Nadir this morning denied a request for Opposition Leader Azruddin Mohamed to participate remotely in parliamentary proceedings from prison, saying his authority over sittings does not extend to directing prison officials to facilitate a member’s participation while that member is on remand.
In giving his reasons, Nadir said parliamentary permission to participate remotely would not, by itself, oblige prison authorities to provide the facilities, access or means of communication needed. He said any such arrangement would require a lawful basis and would have to respect the existing court order.
“The Speaker of the National Assembly has no authority by virtue of that office alone to override an order of remand or to compel the release or the production of a member lawfully detained pursuant to a judicial order,” Nadir said.
He cited the Prison Act, Chapter 11:01, as the law governing the custody of persons committed to prison. He also referred to Standing Order 106, which requires members who are unable to attend sittings to notify the Clerk and provides for the Speaker to grant leave in prescribed circumstances. Nadir said the Standing Orders had to be applied consistently with the Constitution and other laws.
“The Assembly must respect the independence of the judiciary just as the judiciary must respect the constitutional functions of Parliament,” he said. He said he had put his reasons in writing so they would form part of the record of the Speaker’s rulings.
In closing, Speaker Manzoor Nadir said he had to “deny the request of the honourable member”. He added, “I thought I put this in writing so that it forms part of the rulings.”
WIN Chief Whip Tabitha Sarabo-Halley had said at a party press conference that she wrote to the Speaker on Friday seeking permission for Mohamed to participate by Zoom in Wednesday’s sitting if necessary. She said the request followed uncertainty at the previous sitting over what Parliament had agreed to and what arrangements could be made at the prison.
Mohamed has been held at Lusignan Prison since October 30, when Magistrate Abigail Gibbs refused him bail on a Cybercrime Act charge brought jointly against him and Police Constable Ryan Greene. The charge concerns the alleged unauthorised disclosure of surveillance footage of the October 12 shooting outside the Kitty residence of Police Special Branch Head, Senior Superintendent Prem Narine. The High Court refused Mohamed interim bail on November 13. After hearing arguments on his challenge to Gibbs’s decision on Tuesday, Justice Priscilla Chandra-Hanif reserved her ruling until 11 am today.
Discussion