Dear Editor,
I write with reference to the article published on Sunday, November 15, 2026, in Kiskadee Watch, captioned “DPP appeals Chief Magistrate’s decision not to revoke Mohamed’s bail.”
While the Office of the Director of Public Prosecutions (DPP), headed by Ms. Shalimar Ali-Hack, is entirely within its rights to test the boundaries of the Bail Act of 2022, it is imperative that this legal strategy remains bereft of bias, ill-will, and prejudice. The DPP is a constitutional legal officer with a core mandate to independently control criminal prosecutions and protect the rights of the Guyanese people. Her office is constitutionally ring-fenced from the Executive by Article 187 of the Constitution of Guyana, and it must not be seen to pander to political wishes, but every day this appears not to be the case.
The matter in question involves an extradition request by the United States against Mr. Azruddin Mohamed and his father, Mr. Nazar Mohamed. While extradition proceedings are ongoing before Chief Magistrate Ms. Judy Latchman, Mr. Mohamed was arrested and charged with offences that are entirely unrelated to the extradition matter (unlawful possession of firearm/ammunition, attempting to obstruct justice, and cybercrime).
The DPP applied to the Chief Magistrate to revoke the bail granted in the extradition proceedings based on these new charges. The Chief Magistrate refused, grounded in the legal accurate conclusion that the two matters are not related. The DPP has now filed a Judicial Review Application (JRA) in the High Court to quash the Magistrate’s refusal and revoke the bail. However, as learned Senior Counsel Mr. Anil Nandlall himself has previously alluded to, a JRA against a magistrate’s bail related decision is a narrow path. The High Court, when exercising its supervisory jurisdiction, does not act as an appellate court; it does not re-hear the bail application or substitute its own judgment. The High Court is legally bound only to intervene if it is proven that the Magistrate “erred in law, acted irrationally, or exhibited procedural impropriety”.
Magistrate Latchman’s refusal to revoke bail was grounded in a strict, conservative application of evidentiary standards. She reasoned that:
· A conviction is required to definitively prove a breach of bail conditions, or at the very least, charges alone are insufficient.
· The mere filing of charges does not prove that the defendant committed the offence or is likely to commit one.
· There must be “something substantial” beyond just a charge to satisfy the court that the defendant is a risk.
The DPP argues that the Magistrate erred in law by requiring proof of a conviction, pointing to Section 7(1)(c) of the Bail Act 2022. The DPP asserts that establishing the conditions in Section 7(1)(c) does not require proof of a criminal conviction or proof beyond a reasonable doubt.
With respect, this appears to be an unsound position. The foundational legal maxim onus probandi incumbit ei qui dicit, non ei qui negat (he who asserts must prove) dictates that the State must prove its allegations. If Mr. Mohamed is proven guilty of these local offences in a court of law “lock him up in the Tower of London”. However, we must not allow the court of social media or the many PPP media outfits to supplant the Supreme Court of Judicature.
This principle is explicitly guaranteed in Article 144(2)(a) of the Constitution of the Co-operative Republic of Guyana, which states that every person charged with a criminal offence “shall be presumed to be innocent until he is proved or has pleaded guilty.” Our Constitution was crafted to ensure that the Court remains the only forum under the law where a criminal offence is proven with facts and evidence. We must be careful not to erode this fundamental protection or disregard the rule of law in the pursuit of personal or political scores.
What is particularly concerning is the question of who is driving this legal strategy. A critical reading of the DPP’s filings reveals several red flags regarding the Office’s independence. The DPP’s pleadings explicitly state: “The application was drawn on the DPP’s behalf by Celine Deidrick, one of the attorneys for the United States in the extradition case…”
This creates a troubling perception. The DPP is a constitutional office meant to represent the people of Guyana, yet it appears to be allowing US attorneys to do its work in a prejudicial attempt to keep a Guyanese citizen in prison. Can Guyana do the same to a US Citizen in the US Court system? Are we a colony now? This situation suggests that the DPP may be functioning as a proxy for foreign interests rather than an independent arbiter of Guyanese justice, raising serious questions about our sovereignty.
Furthermore, the DPP’s pleadings note that police officers were present to be examined by the Chief Magistrate, but that Magistrate Latchman indicated this was unnecessary. The DPP frames this as a procedural error.. However, bringing a squad of police officers to a bail hearing to introduce highly prejudicial allegations without a full trial suggests an aggressive ambush campaign to ensure the defendant remains incarcerated pre-conviction.
The DPP also filed an urgent JRA to be heard before the Chief Justice on November 23rd, coinciding directly with another bail hearing for Mr. Mohamed before Justice Priscilla Chandra-Hanif. This gives the strong appearance of forum-shopping. By attempting to have the Chief Justice quash the Magistrate’s decision on an urgent basis, the DPP appears to have exercised undue influence to preempt the decision of another High Court judge. This demonstrates an intense, targeted focus on keeping the defendant behind bars at all costs, rather than allowing the normal legal process to unfold.
Additionally, Superintendent Shellon Daniels submitted an 88-page submission for this bail revocation hearing. This massive dossier suggests the prosecution is treating the bail hearing as a full trial on the merits. It is an overwhelming use of state resources against a single individual pre-conviction, raising questions about whether the state, under political bias, is attempting to punish him irrespective of the courts’ decisions.
The prosecution alleges Mr. Mohamed was surveilling Superintendent Prem Narine. Yet, based on publicly available information, this relies on highly circumstantial evidence (being near a house at midnight), to trigger an 88-page dossier and an urgent High Court review. While it may have been ill-advised and rather juvenile for Mr. Mohamed to leave the comfort of his home to go on a jolly-ride at midnight because he got a call when holding such high Constitutional Office, as a citizen of Guyana, he retains the constitutional right to traverse any public road at any time, that is not formally closed.
From these pleadings, the DPP risks being seen as making a determined effort to use all of her influence to weaponize the justice system to manufacture a narrative that Mr. Mohamed is a dangerous threat, thereby justifying his continued detention regardless of the outcome of the underlying charges. These aggressive actions give the strong appearance that the State’s goal is not merely to ensure he appears for trial, but to penalize him before any trial has concluded.
As Guyana proudly hosts the Ninth Biennial Conference of the Caribbean Association of Judicial Officers (CAJO), we must reflect on the principles of justice and judicial independence that we are projecting to the region. We must do everything in our collective power to ensure that our constitutional bodies, including the Office of the DPP and the Guyana Police Force, remain independent and unweaponized. The rule of law must prevail for all citizens. At the end of the day, Guyana is a civilized place; we are not a pig farm.
Yours faithfully,
Surujdai Juglall
Discussion