Times have really changed. On March 27, 2025, visiting US Secretary of State Marco Rubio famously issued a stark warning to the Maduro administration in Caracas which had been engaged in multiple acts of aggression on Guyana’s border. Responding to a question from Stabroek News at State House, Mr Rubio said “It would be a very bad day for the Venezuelan regime if they were to attack Guyana or attack ExxonMobil or anything like it… it would be a very bad day, a very bad week for them, and it would not end well for them”.
The third visit by a US Secretary of State in less than five years when there had been none prior to 2020, underlining the attraction of the massive 2015 oil find here, Mr Rubio made one other statement which is germane to Guyana’s position today as it relates to the longstanding claim by Venezuela to Essequibo.
He stated that Guyana has “our full commitment and support today. We’re demonstrating it both in tangible ways, and we’re going to look for ways to make it long term sustainable, ways to make abundantly clear that we are invested, both as a nation and from our people and being your partner in transformation and in prosperity, and we will not allow illegitimate territorial claims to be an impediment to your dreams and to your right to develop this country, into a symbol that I hope will inspire others to follow the example”. Mr Rubio had declared Venezuela to be pursuing “illegitimate territorial claims” against Guyana.
Just twenty months later, Guyana has now been swept up in a maelstrom of intrigue stretching from the State Department to the White House in which former State Department policy chief Jeremy Lewin – who answered directly to Mr Rubio – initiated talks with the non-elected, interim President of Venezuela Delcy Rodrigues for the ceding of some Essequibo territory to Caracas notwithstanding the fact that Washington had been supposedly on board with an acceptance of the 1899 arbitral award as a full, final and perfect settlement of the boundary of the two countries and awaiting expected affirmation by a ruling of the International Court of Justice (ICJ) sometime next year.
So what had changed? On January 3rd this year, the US seized Venezuelan President Nicolás Maduro in a clinically executed operation that might have laid the foundation for its now disastrous war on Iran. The reins of the Venezuelan government had now fallen into the hands of Ms Rodriguez who was sensible enough to know that despite her constant denunciation of US neocolonialism she, too, could be facing cell time if she did not cooperate with the new overlord – the Trump administration.
For as long as the US’ tarnished history in this region has been discussed and in the backdrop of the revival of the Monroe Doctrine it had been claimed that all that Washington was after in Venezuela were the largest proven reserves of oil globally. That claim finally met its suitor in President Trump. In swift order President Rodriguez, for all of her nationalist tirades, keeled over and surrendered huge oil fields.
On August 31st this year, the White House in its typical grandiloquent language hailed it as the biggest oil deal in world history and said in part “President Donald J. Trump has secured U.S. majority control of more than 65 billion barrels of proven oil reserves in Venezuela – vastly expanding our current U.S. territorial proven reserves of roughly 46 billion barrels. This deal secures our energy dominance for the next century—all at zero cost to the United States. The deal, signed by Secretary of State Marco Rubio and Secretary of War Pete Hegseth, gives the U.S. government powerful governance rights, economic ownership, and guaranteed low-cost off-take from a new private Venezuelan oil champion, which will be the second-largest private oil company by reserves in the world”.
Just weeks later, Mr Lewin was to present his territory-ceding scenario to Guyana’s Foreign Secretary Robert Persaud. The important question hereafter is whether President Rodriguez had struck a deal with Washington that entailed an assurance that it would gain some of Guyana’s territory in return for oil that it was surrendering and that this malign effort then became entrenched in the White House.
No doubt these developments would have shaken President Ali and his team to the core. They lulled themselves into thinking that feting President Trump and kowtowing to every demand from Washington including betraying Cuba would secure support for Guyana’s position that the final word on the boundary with Venezuela would come from the ICJ and there was no prospect whatsoever of bilateral talks let alone a deal on ceding anything to Caracas.
Amateur hour in this PPP/C administration has been exposed and questions must now be answered as to what our Ambassador has been doing in Washington. Understanding the Trump way of doing business the Ambassador should have been sedulously courting the White House to protect Guyana from exactly what it now faces.
The danger continues. The Secretary of War Pete Hegseth – who unsurprisingly recently faced an attempt in the US House to have impeachment proceedings begin against him – struck a defence deal with President Rodriguez this week during which he darkly spoke about territorial recovery for Venezuela. A press release from the US Department of War on November 19 reported Mr Hegseth as stating “the Department of War will work with Venezuela to eradicate threats to both nations, to recover Venezuela’s territory and to undertake profound security and defense reforms”. Further, he said “and the mission now is to transform the nation into a capable partner that reclaims its territory, national identity and prosperity”. Mr Hegseth may not be a student of history and may not be speaking particularly about anything but the allusion to recovery of territory in the context of the oil deal and Mr Lewin’s démarche cannot be simply ignored.
Which now brings us to the startling press release issued by the US Embassy here on Thursday in the aftermath of the frisson over the disclosures about Mr Lewin’s September meeting with Mr Persaud.
It said: “The policy on the land boundary between the two countries has not changed. The United States reaffirms its support for the 1899 Arbitral Award that determined the land boundary between Venezuela and Guyana, which should be respected unless or until a new boundary is set by a competent legal body or with the consent of both parties”.
Up to Mr Rubio’s visit any such statement would have ended at full-throated support for the 1899 arbitral award followed by a full stop. The two qualifications that were appended on Thursday are the byproducts of the vulpine negotiations between the White House and President Rodriguez and the American Ambassador should be summoned by Takuba Lodge to explain their meaning.
In defence of every inch of Essequibo, Georgetown must now hold its course and begin doing more of the work that it should have been doing all along instead of investing its energies in the Trump administration which is completely untrustworthy and 100% transactional without evident signs of principle.
It must embark on a full-scale outreach to each member of the UN security council to present them with a comprehensive dossier on the border controversy. It will have to lean on Trinidad and Tobago which will take up its position on the council next year for support in this endeavour. It must actively mobilize support in other influential countries such as Brazil, India, Canada, Japan, Australia, South Africa and major European capitals in preparation for the ruling of the ICJ and what is expected to follow. When the new US Congress convenes in January a high-level delegation should be dispatched from Georgetown including representatives from the team that presented at the ICJ to underline Guyana’s case before the foreign relations committees. There is no time for inaction and indolence. Vigilance is also required on the border along with full monitoring of the exchanges between Washington and Caracas.
Discussion