Skip to content
https://kiskadeewatch.com/guyana/eight-year-old-mv-barima-survivor-held-moms-weary-hand-as-they-battled-waves-in-darkness/

Eight-year-old MV Barima survivor held mom’s weary hand as they battled waves in darkness

Anndyar Deally and eight-year-old Yosmary


-mother believes son may have survived tragedy had help come sooner

When the MV Barima went down in the darkness off Guyana’s coast, Anndyar Deally found herself fighting for her life, desperately searching for her children while clinging to whatever floating objects she could find.

But as exhaustion threatened to overcome her, it was her eight-year-old daughter, Yosmary, who became her source of strength, urging her not to give up as they struggled through the waves together.

“No, mommy, no, no. Hold on, mommy,” Yosmary told her as Deally, physically drained after hours in the water, thought she could no longer go on.

She reflected on her experience last Friday during the Commission of Inquiry (CoI) which continued at the Arthur Chung Conference Centre at Liliendaal, Greater Georgetown.

Deally, who lives in Port Kaituma, had travelled to Georgetown with family members to obtain birth certificates for her children and shop for her small fast-food business. She had also been carrying items for her pregnant daughter who opted not to return to Port Kaituma with her because of the harsh conditions they had experienced on their trip to Georgetown.

Having travelled on the MV Barima twice before, Deally said she had never experienced the level of overcrowding she saw last July 18. She recalled arriving at Kingston Wharf at about 10:00 hours, where she was surprised by the large number of passengers gathered to board the vessel.

She found a small space near the steps inside the vessel, where she settled with her son, Andriel Bautista (who did not survive), while Yosmary sat on a bench with a 13-year-old girl who was the daughter of an acquaintance.

Deally’s son Andriel Bautista (second from right) did not survive the tragedy

The boat left about 15:00 hours and after resting and eating with her family, Deally said she woke at about 22:00 hours and went to check on her daughter. She then accompanied Yosmary and the 13-year-old girl to the washroom before returning to sit with them. But at about 22:18 hours, everything changed.

Deally recalled hearing a sudden sound before the vessel began tilting to one side. Passengers who had been lying on the floor began rolling as the boat leaned, sending panic through the crowded vessel. Her immediate instinct was to get to her son. But as she tried to make her way towards him, the force of the moving passengers swept her along and sent her out of the vessel. “All I could see was water in the face,” she recalled.

In the water, she began swallowing water before reminding herself that she could swim. She eventually surfaced and found a mattress floating nearby, with two men struggling to hold on to it. Realising that panic could cost them their chance of survival, Deally said she told them they all needed to remain calm. “We got to calm down. Because if we ain’t calm down, none of we gonna get for hold on on this mattress,” she told them. The three managed to hold on, and Deally later grabbed a roll of vinyl.

Anndyar Deally giving testimony last Friday

She said even as a red flare shot into the sky and provided some kind of hope, all she could think of was finding her children. She began praying and calling out their names. Then, from a distance, she heard someone calling her. It was the 13-year-old girl, assuring her that her daughter was with her.

The girl shouted that Yosmary was nearby and holding on to a cooler. Deally could then hear her daughter calling out. “Mommy, I’m right here,” Yosmary shouted.

Deally told her to hold on while she tried to make her way towards her. After eventually reaching her, she asked whether the child could swim across to where she was holding on and Yosmary assured her that she could. They waited for the waves to ease before the little girl swam across and joined her mother.

From then on, the two remained together, holding on to the floating mattress as waves repeatedly crashed against them.

Deally said they continued calling out for her son, nephew and other relatives, but received no response. Hours passed before a plane eventually appeared overhead, circling the area and shining lights into the water before leaving.

Later, Deally and the others managed to reach another group of survivors holding on to a large floating object. Several people gathered together, trying to stay afloat as they awaited rescue.

But the ordeal was taking a devastating physical toll. Deally said her feet were cramping, her hands were becoming too weak to hold on, and she began feeling that she could no longer survive. She had been pushing her hand through the mattress to secure her grip, but eventually even that became difficult. It was then that Yosmary refused to let her mother surrender.

The child offered to hold her hand so that she could rest. “Me gon hold your hand so that you could get for rest,” Yosmary told her, urging her to tell her when she had enough strength to hold on again.

Eventually, they began seeing rescue boats approaching. They shouted for help, but the waves repeatedly covered them, making it difficult for rescuers to locate them.

Deally recalled that rescuers eventually spotted them and began pulling survivors aboard. This process was difficult, though, with some people slipping against the side of the rescue boat as they were being lifted from the water. Even Yosmary struck her chest against the side of the boat.

But the mother and daughter were eventually rescued and transported to Charity. But while Deally and her daughter survived, her son Andriel did not make it. Deally later identified his body on July 20, after searching through groups of recovered bodies.

She said the experience of having to examine the bodies in search of her child was particularly painful. During her testimony, she wore a shirt bearing her son’s name as a reminder of the young life lost.

Deally also recounted being told by another survivor that he had seen her son on a floating object with another person before a wave swept them away in different directions.

Reflecting on what happened, she questioned whether her son might have survived had rescue efforts reached the passengers earlier. She based this assessment on her observation that when she saw his body, it was fully intact unlike all of the others, which suggested to her that he remained alive for a long time.

Questioned by Commissioner Andrzej Jasionowski, Deally explained that she had travelled on the MV Barima twice before, from Port Kaituma to Georgetown, but had never observed water on the lower deck during those trips.

Commissioner Jasionowski described the disclosure as crucial evidence, noting that Deally was the only witness to have provided the Commission with that particular set of information.

Commissioner Nyree Dawn Alphonso questioned Deally about the ticketing arrangements for the trip with Deally explaining that she purchased five tickets on the Wednesday before the tragedy, providing the names of the passengers and her telephone number. She was not asked to present identification or provide individual contact details for the other passengers.

She explained that the ticket clerk entered the information into a computer and asked how many adult and children’s tickets were required before issuing the tickets when she returned to collect them on Saturday morning.

Commissioner Hayden Pritchard questioned Deally about the arrangements for passengers boarding the MV Barima, particularly the makeshift walkway used to transfer passengers from one vessel to the other, and Deally responded that the passengers had to walk across a wooden board placed between the vessels.

He also asked whether the cries for help she heard in the water were in English or Spanish, and she responded hearing both languages.

Pritchard also sought to establish whether a significant number of Venezuelan nationals regularly travelled on the vessel. Deally responded that Venezuelans are often among the passengers on the boat as they could sometimes pass through immigration checks without others realising they were Venezuelan nationals, unlike air travel, where they would encounter immigration procedures.

You reached the end of this article without encountering a paywall.

That is deliberate. We believe reliable journalism about Guyana should be available to everyone from the hinterland to the coast, including those who cannot afford to pay for it. But investigating, reporting and publishing every story takes time, energy and resources. Keeping our journalism open depends on the commitment of readers who can chip in and contribute to help cover the cost for everyone.

Please join the Kiskadee family by taking a subscription. Every contribution counts to our commitment to our journalists, to our readers, and to independent, public-interest journalism.

And please spread the word. One one dutty build dam!

Become a supporter