Over 400 years ago, English explorer Sir Walter Ralegh travelled to the Guianas where he believed he would find the legendary city of gold, El Dorado. In fact, he and other Europeans made several journeys to South America, but never managed to give any credence to the myth. Nevertheless, gold has remained one of the most coveted commodities in the world.
For Guyana, it has long been an important source of wealth creation, employment, foreign exchange, and government revenue. It is even more so at current world market prices (close to US$4,000 an ounce, down from just over US$5,000 in late January, but increased by nearly US$2,500 compared with a decade ago). However, there is another side to the gold story; the cost that is paid in environmental destruction, illness, violence and loss of life.
Illegal mining for precious metals in this country is rampant, which means that in many instances regulations are adhered to in the breach. The authorities do manage to find and prosecute unlicensed prospectors every now and then, but the areas in which they operate are too vast and remote to adequately police. Furthermore, most artisanal and small-scale gold miners, legal or illegal, use the poisonous substance mercury to extract the metal from ore. According to the latest data from the Extractive Industries Transparency Initiative, this category of mining accounts for approximately 88 percent of Guyana’s gold production.
The scale of the problem is particularly troubling when one considers that Guyana’s small and medium-scale mining sector is responsible for an estimated 94 percent of national mercury emissions. The environmental and health consequences are potentially devastating. Mercury released into waterways and soils can enter the food chain, exposing even communities far removed from actual mining operations.
The country has committed itself under the Minamata Convention, which it ratified in 2014, to reducing mercury use. Its updated National Action Plan envisages a phased reduction to 75 percent of baseline consumption by 2027, which is not really ideal. There are also initiatives to encourage mercury-free extraction methods and the use of retorts to capture mercury vapour. These are welcome, but commitments and pilot projects are not the same as measurable results. Guyana’s most recent reported comprehensive mercury emissions inventory dates back to October 2016, which makes it difficult to determine just how much progress has been achieved.
Then there is the violence. Criminal activity in the mining sector deserves considerably more attention than it has received. Gold is valuable, portable and relatively easy to convert into cash. The scramble to acquire it can create opportunities for robbery, theft, disputes over claims and territory, and violence arising from competition for control of mining operations. The presence of large numbers of workers in isolated locations, often beyond the effective reach of law enforcement, can provide fertile ground for criminal activity. Add alcohol, gambling, exploitation and the absence of adequate social and regulatory structures, and the situation becomes even more volatile.
Unfortunately, there are no local studies or publicly available statistics, but one only needs to peruse newspaper archives to find countless reports of bandits raiding mining camps, beating, maiming and murdering in their quest to obtain precious ores. One infamous incident was the June 2008 Lindo Creek massacre, in which eight men were slaughtered and their bodies and belongings burnt, possibly in a bid to destroy evidence. They had been mining for diamonds and had reportedly found a large cache just prior to their murders. And just last month, the police reported that a gang of masked men robbed three mining camps in Region Seven (Cuyuni/Mazaruni) carting off raw gold, cash, and a security guard’s gun.
Lest we forget, there is also the destruction of the environment, the exploitation of vulnerable workers, including minors, and the intrusion of illegal mining into Indigenous territories – the ongoing Chinese Landing saga is a case in point. All of these contribute to conditions in which violence and social disintegration can flourish. The pursuit of gold has surely become an enterprise in which the people who bear the greatest risks are not necessarily those who reap the greatest rewards.
As regards illness, a Lancet study, which examined malaria transmission in Guyana between 2007 and 2019, found a strong positive correlation between international gold prices and malaria infections in mining regions. A one percent increase in the gold price was associated with a 2.13 percent increase in malaria infections among the population most likely to be involved in mining one month later. There was also a 1.63 percent increase in infections among other population groups in mining regions two months later. The researchers concluded that the increase in mining activity associated with higher gold prices was likely to have been a major driver of malaria transmission.
This is not difficult to understand. Higher prices encourage more mining, which attracts workers into remote, forested areas where healthcare facilities are often inadequate. Mining activities also disturb the environment, creating pools of stagnant water that provide breeding grounds for mosquitoes. Workers who contract malaria in these locations can carry the infection back to their home communities, extending the consequences well beyond the mining camps.
The World Health Organisation has also acknowledged the relationship between gold prices and malaria cases in Guyana, pointing to the particular difficulties of reaching highly mobile mining populations with prevention, diagnosis and treatment. It is not an insignificant public health consideration that the price of a commodity can provide an indication of the likely direction of a serious communicable disease. Yet mining activity and public health planning are still treated as separate matters.
None of this is an argument against mining or a denial of its contribution to the economy. Rather, it offers evidence indicating that production and revenue are sufficient measures of success. Therefore, while the country continues to extract its mineral wealth, it must also move decisively to mitigate the damage caused and the lives lost along the way.
In short, the government has a responsibility to ensure that mining is properly regulated. It must also forge ahead with adopting mercury-free technologies, ascertain that abandoned mining pits and degraded lands are rehabilitated, and that health services reach the communities and workers most at risk. Law enforcement must also be capable of addressing the criminal activity that accompanies the scramble for gold, including the protection of people working in remote areas. Finally, there must be greater transparency in the gold supply chain. The origins of the gold and the methods of extraction must be unambiguous and not glossed over by the profits attained.
Discussion