-criticises decisions of magistrate, judge
The Guyana Human Rights Association (GHRA) yesterday said that the continued detention of Opposition Leader Azruddin Mohamed is a “fundamental miscarriage of justice” and it criticised the decisions of the magistrate and judge who have denied him bail.
Saying that the question now arises: “from where, or whom, can the Leader of Opposition now seek and obtain justice?”, the GHRA said that he is entitled to the presumption of innocence.
“Shockingly, the Leader of the Opposition has been on prolonged detention without bail for nearly three weeks now. On Wednesday 18 November, a Judge of the High Court denied his application for bail, overlooking fundamental principles of justice such as the paramountcy of the presumption of innocence. On the same day, the Speaker of Parliament denied a request from WIN that the Leader of the Opposition be allowed to participate in a sitting of Parliament from his detention cell”, the GHRA observed.
In legal proceedings yesterday before Justice Priscilla Chandra-Hanif to hear an application for bail, the GHRA said that it was reported that “Magistrate Abigail Gibbs has told the High Court that she refused Opposition Leader Azruddin Mohammed bail after concluding that the timing of several matters brought against him disclosed a ‘pattern’ and gave her substantial grounds to believe he was likely to commit another ‘offence’ if released.”
The GHRA said that this was an extraordinary statement by the Magistrate. “The concept of a pattern cannot be used in respect of mere charges, or allegations (as opposed to, say, convictions)”, the GHRA contended.
It said that it is worth recalling that thus far, nothing against the Leader of the Opposition has been proved beyond a reasonable doubt in a court of law. Two sets of charges initiated in Guyana, unheard, unproven, cannot possibly be used as evidence of a ‘pattern’. “There is a fundamental error of judgement here”, the GHRA declared.
It said that an accused person, in this instance Guyana’s elected Leader of the Opposition, is entitled to the presumption of innocence on all charges. Magistrate Gibbs’ statement that an alleged ‘pattern’ gave her substantial grounds to believe he was likely “to commit another offence if released” is a flagrant violation of the presumption of innocence. The Leader of the Opposition has not been found to have committed any offence so far, the GHRA said.
It said that in the case before the Magistrate there was also an issue of public interest, namely the legitimate interest of the public to know what happened when the alleged shooting incident with Police Special Branch Head, Prem Narine occurred on October 12th in Kitty.
“The tape released appeared to shed light on this issue. This was surely relevant in the consideration of an application for bail. The Magistrate appears to have acted in a manner seriously prejudicial to the accused who is entitled to be compensated for this miscarriage of justice”, the GHRA asserted.
It added “Unfortunately, the Judge (Chandra-Hanif) hearing the application for bail, disregarding fundamental issues of justice, adopted and confirmed the reasoning of the Magistrate, with the result that Guyana’s Leader of the Opposition may well languish in jail indefinitely. The question now arises: from where, or whom, can the Leader of Opposition now seek and obtain justice?”
Contending that Guyana is a fragile democracy, the GHRA noted that the elections of 2025 resulted in the entry on to the political scene of a new political party, WIN, which won sixteen seats in parliament, making its leader, Mohamed the Leader of the Opposition. GHRA said WIN’s votes came from across the ethnic groupings in the country, inspiring hope of a political future less influenced by ethnic voting.
It noted that the Speaker of the Parliament took an unacceptably long time to convene a meeting of Parliament to formally elect the leader of the Opposition and that the Leader of the Opposition “has been persistently obstructed from carrying out his Constitutional functions ever since he was elected”.
The GHRA called the attention of Guyanese of goodwill, and the international community, to the implications for the future political health of Guyana at this treatment being meted out to Guyana’s Leader of the Opposition.
Discussion