-Opposition raises concerns over ministerial powers, property rights
The National Assembly last night passed the National Heritage Preservation Bill 2026 following an extensive debate in which the Government defended it as a modernisation of heritage protection, while Opposition Members of Parliament (MPs) questioned ministerial powers, State acquisition of private property and protection for property owners and Indigenous communities.
The Bill, presented by Minister of Culture, Youth and Sport Charles Ramson Jr., will repeal the National Trust Act of 1972 and establish a National Heritage Preservation Council responsible for identifying, designating, conserving and protecting the country’s historical and cultural heritage.
It seeks to ensure that places, buildings, monuments, artefacts, traditions and other things of historical, cultural or national importance are not destroyed, neglected, improperly altered or lost.
During his presentation, Ramson said the existing legislation was outdated and did not adequately address several areas, including the protection of private heritage property, archaeological discoveries, underwater heritage, heritage districts and the management of a national heritage register.
He told the National Assembly, at the Arthur Chung Conference Centre, Liliendaal, that the legislation was the culmination of approximately three years of work and more than 50 meetings, pointing to consultations with international organisations.
However, Opposition MPs argued that despite the extensive preparation, the legislation had not received sufficient parliamentary scrutiny and contained provisions that could give the Government considerable control over heritage properties and the proposed Council.
Multiple MPs expressed concern over the extent of ministerial authority under the legislation even as Ramson sought to defend the institutional arrangements, noting that the Council would be guided by professional expertise and would have the necessary authority to carry out its responsibilities.
But APNU MP Ganesh Mahipaul said the Bill required stronger safeguards against political interference. He disclosed that his party had submitted 13 proposed amendments, including one to Section 3 which would replace certain ministerial authority with approval by the National Assembly through a resolution.
Mahipaul also proposed amendments to Section 4 to prevent the Minister from interfering in individual applications, nominations, objections, investigations and enforcement proceedings.
A similar concern was raised by Forward Guyana Movement MP Amanza Walton-Desir, who questioned provisions allowing the Minister to issue general directions to the Council and revoke the appointments of members. She argued that the legislation needed clearer limits on ministerial involvement and safeguards to ensure that members could perform their duties independently.
APNU MP Riaz Rupnarain also called for greater independence, recommending protected terms for Council members, clear grounds for removal, transparent appointments and stronger accountability mechanisms.
Tourism Minister Susan Rodrigues, however, defended the proposed composition of the Council, noting that it was designed to bring together the professional expertise required to manage the country’s heritage. She rejected calls to expand its membership unnecessarily, warning that doing so could create bureaucracy and undermine efficiency.
Rodrigues also pointed out that any person could submit a written nomination to the Council for a site to be considered for heritage designation, arguing that the process was not intended to exclude any ethnic group or section of society.
Another major point of contention was the Bill’s provisions concerning private property and compulsory acquisition.
Ramson said that the proposed legislation would protect private ownership and address shortcomings in the existing law, under which declaring a property a national monument could result in ownership vesting in the National Trust. He said the new framework would allow heritage protection without automatically transferring privately owned property to the State.
Minister Steven Jacobs reinforced that position, insisting that the legislation was about preservation rather than acquisition. He explained that the designation of a heritage site did not automatically transfer ownership of the property or give the State ownership of the cultural and spiritual beliefs associated with it.
However, Mahipaul challenged that explanation, drawing attention to Clause 69 on page 56 of the Bill, which deals with compulsory acquisition. He argued that the provision gives the Minister the final determination after receiving a report, and questioned whether that arrangement adequately protected property owners.
Walton-Desir also raised concerns about the restrictions on transferring designated heritage property, questioning why the Bill appeared to limit changes in ownership to inheritance or sale without making adequate provision for gifts to children or transfers into family trusts.
She further questioned provisions requiring owners to maintain heritage properties, particularly the power of the Council to give nine days’ notice, undertake repairs and recover the costs from owners. She argued that the legislation needed to explain how owners could challenge repair estimates and what assistance would be available to families, churches and community organisations unable to afford specialist preservation work.
Rupnarain similarly called for independent property valuations, transparent compensation procedures, clear payment deadlines and an independent appeals mechanism. He pointed out that citizens should not be left with extensive restrictions on their property while having insufficient safeguards to challenge decisions made by the Council.
WIN Opposition MP Odessa Primus warned that the legislation could give the State excessive powers over citizens, their property and community rights, and she questioned the transparency surrounding the proposed Council’s composition and the extent of consultation undertaken, noting that the people appointed to oversee national heritage should reflect the country’s diversity.
WIN MP Dawn Hastings-Williams stated that Indigenous peoples should have guaranteed representation on the proposed Council, rather than relying on the possibility of being consulted or co-opted. She said that Indigenous communities were not merely stakeholders but had a direct relationship with their ancestral lands, sacred sites, cultural practices and traditional knowledge.
She called for meaningful consultation and free, prior and informed consent in decisions affecting Indigenous heritage.
Minister Sarah Browne-Shadeek dismissed suggestions that the Bill would undermine Indigenous rights, saying it must be read alongside the Constitution and the Amerindian Act of 2006, which remains in force. She cited Article 149G of the Constitution, which provides for the protection, preservation and promulgation of Indigenous languages, cultural heritage and way of life.
Browne-Shadeek also argued that the legislation did not automatically remove ownership of titled Amerindian lands and said existing protections for Amerindian villages would continue to apply.
Mahipaul nevertheless proposed that a representative nominated by the National Toshaos Council be included on the Heritage Council, saying that Indigenous representation should not be left solely to the discretion of the Minister or the Council.
Meanwhile, Rodrigues highlighted the possible relationship between heritage preservation and tourism, welcoming the inclusion of a tourism representative on the Council. She said that properly managed heritage tourism could create opportunities for local guides, craft producers, cultural practitioners and community-owned businesses, particularly outside Georgetown.
She further noted that tourism-related activities, including guided tours, admission fees and concessions, could also provide additional resources for conservation and site management, provided preservation remained the priority and communities benefited from the opportunities created.
Also making a contribution was APNU MP Nima Flue-Bess who argued that the legislation does not adequately protect Guyana’s intangible cultural heritage. She advocated for the Bill to be referred to a Special Select Committee for further examination.
According to the bill’s explanatory memorandum, listing a property as having heritage significance, formally designating it for protection and declaring it national heritage are separate steps. A privately owned site or district would remain in private hands after designation, subject to preservation duties and a notation in the land or deeds records. Before designation, the owner or occupier would have to be notified. Owners and others likely to be affected could object, and the council would appoint an arbiter to hear their objections.
Under Clause 64, an owner intending to sell would have to give the council the “first option to purchase.” Clause 69 would allow compulsory acquisition in specified circumstances, including where property is neglected or endangered or its protection cannot reasonably be secured by other means. The minister would need a report from the council and would have to be satisfied that acquisition was necessary “in the public interest and for the benefit of future generations.”
The Chief Valuation Officer would assess compensation at market value as of the date the acquisition order was published. Payment would be due within 12 months, and either party could take an acquisition dispute to the High Court. The council could also enter property for inspection or specified preservation work after giving at least seven days’ written notice. In certain cases, it could recover reasonable repair costs from the owner or occupier.
Discussion