Skip to content
https://kiskadeewatch.com/guyana/norton-rejects-bilateral-negotiations-with-venezuela-walton-desir-seeks-clarity-on-hegseths-remarks/

Norton rejects bilateral negotiations with Venezuela, Walton-Desir seeks clarity on Hegseth’s remarks


-Todd, Persaud silent on US territory proposal

Foreign Affairs Minister Hugh Todd and Foreign Secretary Robert Persaud have not answered questions from Kiskadee Watch on the reported US proposal for Guyana to cede territory to Venezuela or on qualifications in the US Embassy’s subsequent reaffirmation of support for the 1899 Arbitral Award.

Although the Ministry of Foreign Affairs issued a general assurance on Thursday that Washington’s position remained unchanged, it did not specifically address the reported proposal by then senior US State Department official Jeremy Lewin or explain what response Guyanese officials gave when it was raised.

Forward Guyana Movement Leader Amanza Walton-Desir, responding to Kiskadee Watch’s questions through a press statement yesterday, called for clear answers and meaningful consultation with the opposition. APNU leader Aubrey Norton, who was asked the same questions, declined to interpret the Embassy’s wording as a change in US policy but firmly rejected bilateral negotiations with Venezuela.

The unanswered questions concern the Embassy’s reference to a “competent legal body”, rather than expressly naming the International Court of Justice (ICJ), and its statement that a new boundary could be established with the consent of both countries.

“The policy on the land boundary between the two countries has not changed. The United States reaffirms its support for the 1899 Arbitral Award that determined the land boundary between Venezuela and Guyana, which should be respected unless or until a new boundary is set by a competent legal body or with the consent of both parties,” the Embassy stated on November 19.

Reliance

 Kiskadee Watch reported yesterday that those qualifications had raised further concerns, given Guyana’s position that the Award settled the boundary and its reliance on the ICJ proceedings to resolve Venezuela’s challenge to its validity. Reuters had reported that Lewin offered to facilitate territorial talks during a September meeting with Persaud in Washington and floated the possibility of Venezuela taking partial control of Essequibo.

Todd and Persaud were sent two questions via WhatsApp:

“Has the government sought clarification on why the Embassy referred to a ‘competent legal body’ rather than expressly naming the ICJ? Has Washington unequivocally confirmed that it will respect the Court’s final judgment?”

“Given Guyana’s position that its territory is not negotiable, has the government challenged the Embassy’s reference to a new boundary being established ‘with the consent of both parties’? Has Washington confirmed that it will not pursue or promote territorial concessions or negotiations outside the ICJ process?”

Both officials were also invited to comment on the reported suggestion that Guyana cede territory, including the government’s response when it was raised. Neither answered the messages, and repeated follow-up calls yielded no response.

The ministry’s Thursday statement acknowledged that the territorial controversy was discussed during a September meeting between Guyanese and US State Department officials. It said the focus was the pending ICJ ruling and reaffirming US support for the process, adding that Guyana had received assurances that Washington’s position remained unchanged.

Welcomed

Walton-Desir welcomed the Embassy’s reaffirmation of support for the Award and acknowledged the longstanding Guyana-US relationship. However, she said citizens were entitled to more than general assurances.

“We the people of Guyana are entitled to more than general assurances. We are entitled to know precisely what concerns the Government has raised, what clarification it has sought, and what responses and assurances it has received. On a matter of such consequence, silence and ambiguity simply will not suffice,” she stated.

Her statement also sought clarification of remarks by US Secretary of War Pete Hegseth during his November 18 visit to Caracas, where the United States and Venezuela announced renewed military cooperation.

She acknowledged that published accounts placed his remarks about recovering Venezuelan territory in the context of addressing criminal networks. Nevertheless, she said references to the country’s borders and territory warranted a clear explanation.

The US Department of War’s account quoted Hegseth as saying peace would require Venezuela to “regain its borders and territory”, alongside discussion of confronting narcoterrorism and other security threats.

“While the Department’s account described his remarks in the context of cooperation to address narcoterrorism and other threats, we believe their reference to Venezuela’s borders and territory warrants a clear explanation of what he meant,” Walton-Desir said.

She called on the government to seek urgent clarification from Washington and communicate the answers to the nation.

“We reiterate our full support for the process before the International Court of Justice and our position that the 1899 Arbitral Award constitutes a full, perfect and final settlement of the land boundary between Guyana and Venezuela. We await the judgment of the Court and reject any negotiated settlement of the controversy over the Award,” she stated. 

“The Government cannot treat the Guyanese people as bystanders on a matter that goes to the heart of our sovereignty and territorial integrity. It must engage the Opposition in timely and meaningful consultation and address the nation fully and frankly.”

Cautious

Norton, meanwhile, took a more cautious view of the Embassy’s wording, saying he did not wish to attribute an intention to Washington that it had not expressly stated.

“I don’t want to impute anything whatsoever to the fact that they didn’t mention the International Court of Justice specifically,” he told Kiskadee Watch.

He noted that the ICJ was a competent legal body and said APNU welcomed Washington’s assurance that its position had not changed. His interpretation was that the United States continued to recognise the Award as having settled the boundary and that the proceedings were properly before the Court.

Norton distinguished Guyana’s established boundary from Venezuela’s challenge to the Award.

“As far as Guyana is concerned, the border was settled by the arbitral award of 1899,” he said, explaining that the validity of that Award was the issue before the ICJ.

Asked about the Embassy’s reference to the consent of both countries, Norton distinguished what might be inferred from the statement from what Washington had actually said. However, he was unequivocal about APNU’s opposition to bilateral negotiations.

“But as it relates to negotiations between the two parties, as far as we are concerned, that is ruled out at present,” he said.

He pointed to the avenues already pursued under the Geneva Agreement, including the UN good offices process, before the controversy reached the Court. Guyana, as a small country, would face an unequal power relationship in negotiations with Venezuela, he argued.

“We would never recommend bilateral negotiations. We want to see the issue resolved before the International Court of Justice and that is why we urge the government to stay the course and ensure that it is settled by the ICJ,” Norton said.

He also cautioned against treating foreign policy assurances as permanently fixed, irrespective of changing circumstances.

“Foreign policy is about interests,” he said, pointing to the oil resources of Guyana and Venezuela and the interests of the United States.

Guyana had to pursue its own interests diplomatically and build support for resolving the controversy through multilateral institutions, Norton argued. This required a consistent national approach supported by government-opposition engagement.

“The government needs to engage the opposition so that we have clear agreement. And even when governments change in other countries, we have a consistent structured approach that can be utilized to protect our sovereignty and territorial integrity,” he said.

In a separate statement yesterday, APNU rejected the reported suggestion that Guyana consider ceding territory and pledged support to the government in defending the country.

“No part of our territory must be ceded to Venezuela, and there must be no arrangement that allows Venezuela’s involvement in, or control over, any part of Essequibo. On this basis and this issue, the government of Guyana is reassured of the support of the APNU,” it stated.

The partnership welcomed Washington’s reaffirmation of its position, urged the government to remain on the ICJ course and said both countries should abide by the Court’s ruling.

APNU also proposed a government-opposition policy framework covering territorial integrity and related immigration matters, including cross-border migration and arrangements proposed by foreign governments.

“Timely briefings and consultations before commitments by the government would help Guyana speak with one voice and support consistent policies as foreign governments change course,” it said.

You reached the end of this article without encountering a paywall.

That is deliberate. We believe reliable journalism about Guyana should be available to everyone from the hinterland to the coast, including those who cannot afford to pay for it. But investigating, reporting and publishing every story takes time, energy and resources. Keeping our journalism open depends on the commitment of readers who can chip in and contribute to help cover the cost for everyone.

Please join the Kiskadee family by taking a subscription. Every contribution counts to our commitment to our journalists, to our readers, and to independent, public-interest journalism.

And please spread the word. One one dutty build dam!

Become a supporter